Politeia

338 Pages·2016·3.3 MB·English

1 ( 6 ) / 2015
UNIWERSYTET IM. ADAMA MICKIEWICZA
Wydawnictwo Naukowe Instytutu Filozofii UAM
RADA NAUKOWA
GEORGE ARABATZIS / Ateny / SEWERYN BLANDZI / Warszawa /
ALDO BRANCACCI / Roma / LOREDANA CARDULLO / Katania /
MICHAEL ERLER / Würzburg / DANILO FACCA / Warszawa /
REFIK GÜREMEN / Istanbul / CHRISTOPH JEDAN / Groningen /
ANNA KELESSIDOU / Ateny / AGNIESZKA KIJEWSKA / Lublin /
RYSZARD LEGUTKO / Kraków / YURIY MOSENKIS / Kijów /
ANDRÉ MOTTE / Liège / MELINA G. MOUZALA / Patras /
LIDIA PALUMBO / Neapol / MARIA PROTOPAPAS-MARNELI / Ateny /
CHRISTOF RAPP / Monachium / PAVEL REVKO-LINARDATO / Taganrog /
LIVIO ROSSETTI / Perugia / ALONSO TORDESILLAS / Aix ‑en ‑Provance /
George Zografidis / Saloniki / JÁN ZOZUĽAK / Nitra /
REDAKTOR NACZELNY
MARIAN WESOŁY
ZESPÓŁ REDAKCYJNY
MIKOŁAJ DOMARADZKI / sekretarz redakcji /
EMANUEL KULCZYCKI / ARTUR PACEWICZ
REDAKCJA TOMU
MIKOŁAJ DOMARADZKI
ARTUR PACEWICZ
PROJEKT GRAFICZNY
KRZYSZTOF DOMARADZKI / PIOTR BUCZKOWSKI
WYDAWCA ADRES REDAKCJI
Wydawnictwo Naukowe PEITHO / Examina Antiqua
Instytutu Filozofii UAM Wydawnictwo Naukowe
Instytutu Filozofii UAM
ul. Szamarzewskiego 89 C
60 ‑569 Poznań ul. Szamarzewskiego 89 C
60 ‑568 Poznań
Email: [email protected]
Please note that the online version, ISSN 2082 ‑ 7539
accessible at peitho.amu.edu.pl, is
the original version of this journal.
Commentarius Peitho / Examina Antiqua in Instituto Philosophiae Universitatis
Studiorum Mickiewiczianae Posnaniensis conditus id spectat, ut in notissimis toto orbe
linguis, lingua quoque Latina et nostra lingua Polona minime exclusa, antiquorum philo­
sophorum opera atque cogitationes nec non earum apud posteros memoria longe lateque
propagentur. Non exstitit adhuc in Polonia commentarius, quem docta societas interna­
tionalis legeret; at nostra magnopere interest gravissimas philosophiae antiquae quaes­
tiones, cultui atque humanitati totius Europae fundamentales, communiter considera­
ri, solvi divulgarique posse. Namque philosophia, Graecorum et Romanorum maximi
momenti hereditas, hodie novis scientiarum rationibus et viis adhibitis ab integro est
nobis omni ex parte meditanda et disputanda.
Itaque charactere internationali commentarius hic variarum terrarum et gentium homi­
nibus doctis permittet, ut credimus, cogitationes, investigationes, laborum effectus
magno cum fructu commutare et instrumentum doctorum fiet utilissimum ad se invi­
cem persuadendum, ut antiquus id suggerit titulus (Latine Suada), quem scripto nostro
dedimus. Sed commentarius hic late patefactus est quoque omnibus rebus, quae philo­
sophiae sunt propinquae et affines, quae ad temporum antiquorum atque Byzantino­
rum culturam lato sensu pertinent, quae eiusdem denique philosophiae fortunam aetate
renascentium litterarum tractant. In nostra Peitho praeter commentationes scientificas
doctae disputationes quoque et controversiae atque novorum librorum censurae locum
suum invenient. Itaque omnes, qui philosophiae favent, toto exhortamur animo et invi­
tamus, ut nostri propositi participes esse dignentur.
MARIAN WESOŁY MIKOŁAJ DOMARADZKI

SPIS TREŚCI
ARTYKUŁY
THOMAS ALEXANDER The Dokounta of the Platonic Dialectician 13
SZLEZÁK

HANS JOACHIM KRÄMER Niepisana nauka Platona 25

MICHAEL ERLER Platona krytyka pisma/oralności oraz teoria 45
pryncypiów

SALVATORE LAVECCHIA Agatologia del molteplice. Considerazioni 59
sulla Dualità Indeterminata

RAÚL GUTIÉRREZ Widerspruch und Aphairesis in Platons 71
Politeia

ANNA MOTTA Platone e i “caccatori di uccelli”: la contro­ 93
versa eredità di un cigno incatturabile
incatturabile

CRISTIANA CASERTA Tιμιώτερα Libri, oggetti parlanti, onore e 113
vergogna nel Fedro

YOSEF Z. LIEBERSOHN Persuasion, Justice and Democracy in Plato’s 147
Crito

MELINA G. MOUZALA Syrianus on the Platonic Tradition of the 167
Separate Existence of Numbers
MICHAIL MANTZANAS La réincarnation chez Platon et l’optique 195
chrétienne

MARIAN WESOŁY Świadectwa niepisanej dialektyki Platona 205

DYSKUSJE

ENRICO VOLPE Dal senso alla ragione, dalla ragione al 269
senso

ENRICO PIERGIACOMI La scienza, il vortice, il metodo analogico 273
nei Milesi

MASSIMO PULPITO Il crocevia ontologico e i due volti della 285
Doxa. Un’apologia della terza via in
Parmenide

WALTER FRATTICCI Parmenide: suoni, immagini, esperienza. 295
A proposito di una nuova lettura

MAGDALENA Z ziemi do Hadesu i z powrotem, czyli 331
bizantyńska satyra Timarion
JAWORSKA-WOŁOSZYN
CONTENTS
ARTICLES
THOMAS ALEXANDER The Dokounta of the Platonic Dialectician 13
SZLEZÁK

HANS JOACHIM KRÄMER Plato’s Unwritten Doctrine 25

MICHAEL ERLER Plato’s Critique of Writings/Orality and 45
Theory of Principles

SALVATORE LAVECCHIA Agathology of Multiplicity. Considerations 59
concerning the Indetermined Duality

RAÚL GUTIÉRREZ Contradiction and Aphairesis in Plato’s 71
Republic

ANNA MOTTA Plato and “the Birdhunters”: The Contro­ 93
versial Legacy of an Elusive Swan

CRISTIANA CASERTA Tιμιώτερα Books, Talking Objects, Honour 113
and Shame in the Phaedrus

YOSEF Z. LIEBERSOHN Persuasion, Justice and Democracy in Plato’s 147
Crito

MELINA G. MOUZALA Syrianus on the Platonic Tradition of the 167
Separate Existence of Numbers
MICHAIL MANTZANAS Reincarnation in Plato and in the Christian 195
Perspective

MARIAN WESOŁY Testimonies on Plato’s Unwritten Dialectic 205

DISCUSSIONS

ENRICO VOLPE From Sense to Reason, from Reason to 269
Sense

ENRICO PIERGIACOMI Science, Vortex and Analogical Method in 273
the Milesians

MASSIMO PULPITO Ontological Crossroads and the Two Faces 285
of Doxa. An Apology of the Third Way in
Parmenides

WALTER FRATTICCI Parmenides: Sounds, Images, Experience. 295
A Suggestion of a New Reading

MAGDALENA From Earth to Hades and Back, or the 331
Byzantine Satire Timarion
JAWORSKA-WOŁOSZYN