Menimbang Ajaran Syi'ah : 188 Pertanyaan Kritis

95 Pages·2011·6.32 MB·Indonesian

Buku ini telah dimuat-turun
dari perpustakaan Aqeedah.
http://www.aqeedeh.com/my/
E-mail: [email protected]
Laman web yang berguna dalam bahasa Farsi
:
www.aqeedeh.com www.nourtv.net
www.islamtxt.com www.sadaislam.com
www.ahlesonnat.com www.islamhouse.com
www.isl.org.uk www.bidary.net
www.islamtape.com www.tabesh.net
www.blestfamily.com www.farsi.sunnionline.us
www.islamworldnews.com www.sunni-news.net
www.islamage.com www.mohtadeen.com
www.islamwebpedia.com www.ijtehadat.com
www.islampp.com www.islam411.com
www.videofarda.com www.videofarsi.com

����·
.
PerpustakaaNna sioRIn:Ka alta lDoga laTme rbi(taKDT)n
-
·��")�
Al-KharSauslyaiib,mi aSnnh alih T
--��
MenimbAajnagrS ayanih ':1 8p8e rtanyaan
kri/tS iusl aibmiaSnnh alailh- Kshyair;a
penerjAehmmaahSd,y aik-J-hauk a:r ta � SulbaiSinhma aalln-i Kh�h arasyi
PustAatk-aT a2z00k9i.a ,
xi+i 1i6h6i ;m1 .7.c5m
JudAusll i: qAasds'ayital baahb Menimbang
asy-Siylaial' -aHha q.
ISB9N7 8-979-24-2653-3
1.Syiah.IIJ.udulI.AI.hmad
Syaikhu.
AjSayria'na h
297.82
18P8e rytaaaKnnr itis
it
I. �
Pusta.k:a�a�t -Tazkia
�W�C: .
•� ��
�1
"
�ah....,\
�\�W.Q.�u
"
J-4-1J l
As'QialdaShay ta baasyb- Syiila'ala -hH aq
PengaPnetnaerr bit
Penulis:
SulaibmiSanhn a alli-hK harasyi
Penerbit:
MaktaDbaaarhl -MicnehItaI1.j 4 ,2H 8.I2 00M7.
£,
EdiIsnid onesia: Segapluajb ia gAil lahR absbe mesatlaa m.
MenimbAajnagrS ayni 'ah Shaladwaanst a lasme nantiasaa ttaNesar blii mpah
Muhammakde,l uardgaapnna yrsaaa habatnya.
18P8e rtanKyraiatni s
Dia ntara yparndigin asniouplt eA hh lSuusn nah
Penerjemah:
waJla maaiha,lh aahtd ia nl ismaenr ebkear sih ter­
AhmaSdy aikhu
hadappa rsaa habRaats uluslelbaahg,a idmiatnea­
Muraj&a E'daiht or:
TiPmu staatk-aT azkia rangoklaeAnhl l�a:h
DesSaaimnp ul: :#-'
Yudialrstkoa ndar d ljjj ,-:-))�� �:�! J: �� Jr.,
TatLae tak:
JJ .,... .,,, """"' ,. ,:
TiPmu staatk-aT azkia �_,ljJ � �1� J �'?-1j
'lj G� ��I
Penerbit:
Pustaatk-aT azkia
JIM.a tarDaamlaIanRIm T O1 6/N0ol87. B - Jak1a0r3t2a0 �!', _j,,,..J y,,j �J) .....,.l.:.,,,,. �� •j -., l,l;0!,.,,, �� --./�
_p
Tel0p2.1 -47804695 9490,32 2F2a 0x2.1 -0319204 "Daonr ang-yoarnadgna gt asnesgu damhe reka
E-maaittl a:z [email protected]
(MuhadjaiAnrn isnh amre)r,eb kear d'oYaRa,a bb
CetaPkearnt RaambaAi:ku hl1i 4r3H 0.IA pr2i0l0M 9. kambie,r aim punklaamhdi a ns audara-saudara
Dilamreamnpge rbiasbniuy kiauntk ia nipzati enr dtauprleiin se rbit kamyia ntge lbaehr im/aenbd iahh udlaurk ia mi,
AI rIi grhets ervecf
Hatke rjdeimlaihnu dnudnagnig -undang
membirakna kedegnknia merek'acl an me mei l·a rah w as1Raastu lahu .\lJ;;,�l tlen atng
ddoaanmlj ahganatnkialam hEi tn gehkurada apo rnag-ornagy agMnb aeha­r dmreiK rheuk,amd. "·im A a nka ub e lia.mu· eb e nrgskdmbaa ag p/aadkitaeapk epanna.d tAns1 all · aw a Gbheha -r,,.
kamis,esu ngguhnyEan kgau
imanY aR albbai gM ahaP eynnayagn.'"( lA-aHsyr: ke nadaenn gkaenl uarg(aHkRMu.u. s,l,i m)
Peynnatnu �reka juag menciain atrapi sNtarbi,i b uik au m
10) � .
;i: Mu mm,cla n mengianmiba hw a�erekaa dalah pa�
M;,.s-,e r::i;.ek1a' -m.) 'e\ n'.,)a" a.ts�iabd� a 0 N <,?ab.ili-l" '.,>, ._..i;.:,, '1 1J!, _;...J•, :;.: "'l 1 raiN snatyamr duiSianky h airihat'' e er brebtuada t 1a mK8hd0eda lr a aJaJhtcld eann Againaks ehy.ya-
�-�,.;��.l -�j!J �(�', � .b--( kiann yangd ainuAth lu s unSna h.M ereka menacc.1
,,, .
"Jnaga,,ln amhe n,,a., c cmia ikp aars aahbtjaki.auDs k eaamlih tmelaka1mp haurr astd hsaaeapbeanti anbN�·lg� . g; bd�' �en cudauuh�b m eeerberkaaas p oreanmagu
DszoeaUrtynhau nagddg jianw, i nia arutksbaay akcei altariuadtma d iaenitdkna m a gfeannaknhaN-ackyapanie, sm auast mseue bd­ sBdajaaka'anayar U li,m-tS aMuadmri laab q Unniad1ts a n Fa mal - d.an-t e nsAA h1bs.IaM ;uD ee zrra aerkad,mam m Ammpaseh aa nr k Auum.bh1ldY a 'abnAy usgir
sars peaurhm udy agn dinaafkhank sahl sa­e telahd iebrwia saito elh Nabi ntuku men.aJd .1k halaih.f
aoatruna gd aimr erke.a"( HR.A lBu-khardain M usl)im Meerkam enuduhA iyas h sbea g a1. mana tuhdaun yang
mdNmcliAyraaueaeynnmakbanruteMan sw k k ,aBegMeeaaammildarabe e a kmimaetar laeaeknhpadernhkaigwanya ake Utiarm,a nrAac myem a y beAbnli kmeenauabumbnaerh a tkh atkBwdialick ae,naapaesknalruliekahimaa ht Msksiyhh ae uarnf aau bstdAa n ledaad hkbtaaii hlaegeinblairnkKlmarkbianUe fh Uianitaaid-s.i tedsm RaRAmtiapainr ala akrsnaauaalsk nrgmnu abuie kaya nlsiill �as de ht,tada un uAredmanaas ur wheabhi.el nAloil, araaytKeimT ;iygh lllaa ket$,ane.hea dhmU t ian aalmNts lu.yr S cddaneaaimima•nnibi laiaaaptgbnneih gai­­ ­ YddktmsBuaaad ieukera qmk aKS brlmyhr.bi uekaaa be tm nuldyaeh anlanarzcwuumg-laaa.-ao buamiSj ml Mpelaehia lKa- lylhb iikrrateab pdwiiitnsh'aia aasudai na b'rmBsaei t -a Nahdkst, /_,aepil i aheb eme ay .bna tn giiktynelaa�hlag aiann I ribe n-daaA- ab,nbaaa ndn m njrz.I d -im d asyQbi kwu .: e ulehe·erm ua rei u Mraak lral 1krklte kuknai le n ryr" ua dkdah,�, kean esaa1 lae abM p J.nt(u ey eus MatrU rAhmSr�p1 aaua hagth amsa a m1.ya1elll iJk1/n. mm aa. --'t-Jbu,a'mn K l a- d,go'- fki)
mi'ayha,np ga njan7g0nh yaasd tean ghaans Ntaab i
(lubairau snat uukku rkaints aubc Dii!d )a.l amtneyra­
tulsiesm uyaa nhga lclaalny anhga rasme,r steam ua
yandgi butumhaknauns( isae bagadiimsaenbau tkan
al-Kudlaaliaanmli - KJaufgiMa)u .s hFaaft hiymaanhg,
did alamnyaa dtasi adtauk p auynda atrK ii tabullah. Daftalrs i
Kitianbai d aldaihk dtaerR ia suludlelnagthau nl isan
tangAaln(i s ebagadiimsaenbaud taklaaBnmi haa/r­
Anwakra ryaM uhammaBda qiarl -Masjeloirsain,g
ulamSay i'yaahns ge mpdaitb angga-boalneghg akan
seortaonkgdo ihI ndonkeasrieakn aary aniytayu a ng J>�11!Ja11Pteil11r� r.l>.i.t. ........................\1....i.i. .....
tebalsneyraa tjuislaPined r)t.a nyakaennnakypiaat, a b
Daftlas.ri. .....................................x...i.. ...........
suctie rsteibdudatik k elupaardksaaa naA tlm ie njadi
khalibfaahhkh,ai nn gsgaaa t ini?
ltlt1l<c1<l<l•i•111•il•lt• ••••••••••••••••••••••1•• .•••••••••••••••••••••
Seratusan perltaaniynsaneaypnau Stkyariri' taihs PertanySaeapnu tAajra rSayni '.a.h. ....6. ...........
clanb erbakgoanit raadjiakrsayina nnybgai sdai telaah
Te11tc1A11l!Ji 13lc1.ii. t. ..............................�.. ..........
dalabmu kiun Die.n graenef r enysaina gk urlaatn g­
sundga rkii tab-iknidtSuaykbi 'saehm,a kmienn am­ TentgaI nmaMma hd.i. .......................3..7. ........
bahb obobtu kiun Dii.h arapkanS,y i'yoaarhna gn g
Kitab-kSiutcaSiby ' ia .h. ...................4..4.. ........
membacaankyakane mbkaelpia kdeab enakreamn­,
bakleip aSduan naBhu.kl ua ngykaa�p ga ntuanntgu k 1.A l-Ja.m.i.'.a.h. ........................4..4.. ...................
dilewatkan.
2.S hahiafna-hN a.m.u.s. ...........................4...5.. ..
3.S hahiafla-h' Ab.i.t..h.a.h.. .........4..5.. ................
4.ShahiDfzauh' abah( Sahsa-hSiafiafh
yanagd dai p angpkeadla .n.g.). .....4.6. .............
5.S hahiAfl.ai.h . ............4.7. .................................
ApakpaahrS aa haTbealtMa uhr tSaedt elah
6.A l-J.a.f.r.. ............................4.8. .....W.a.f.a.t.Rn.a.ys.au. l..�u.?l.. l..a..h.. ......... ......9...8... ..........
7.M ushFaaft hi.m.a..h.. ...........4..9. ....N.a.b.d.ia. In.m ..aT.mi. .dA.a.dk.aB . e.d.a.n ya
MenuSryuit' .a.h.?.. ...................1...2..2.. ..... ......
8.T aurlantdj,ai Znla b.u.r. .......5.0. ......................
Sy'ai hM enciAnhtlBaiai i. t.?. ........1..2..7.. ... .....
AI-QuMreannu VreurtSs yii .'.a.h. ...56.· . ............
Sya-rsaytaKreaitm a.m.a.n. ........1..3..6.. .... .......
KekhilaAflbaiih Anab nTi h al�i .b. .....7..9.. .. ..
TentSaunmgb er KeSiyli.m'.ua.ah.n . 1.3.8. .......
TentMaanhgad li- Mun.t.a.z.h.a.r. .9.1. ...............
a.S iapalkbaauhl -Ma.h.d.i.?. .....9.3. ....................
b.K apaDnil ahir.k.a.n.?. .........9..3.. .. ....................
c.B agaimlabnuanM yean gandun.g.n.y.9a.3?. .....
d.B agaimlabnuanM yeal ahirk.a.n.n.y.9a.3?. .......
e.B agaimlaaTn uam bu.h.?. .......9.4. ....................
fD.i m anaklaaTh i ng.g.a.l.?. .....9.4. .....................
g.Apaklaaah k aKne mbSaelbia Pgeamiu da
·atauKkeamhb Saelbia Ograainy ga ng
Sudah .T.u.a.?.. ..................9.5. ........................
h.B eraLpaam Maa sKae kuasaa.n.n.y.9a.5?. .......
iB.a gaimMaansGaah aib.n.y.a.?. ...9.6. ...............
Mukaddimah
Segaplubaja igA il l�a yha nbge rfinnan:
S,..!J,,,,.•,
� ..,·IJ1 �::�- ':J,,- - '- ..,·., 'Il .,��- ' ,L •"I -: u.,"� I,; '
u -
� J o� ·-�d 1$'J'vf' ..l.!..A
E. , .,, .,J � .,., ,.
��-:·,:r-�J_p
"Dabna hw(ay aKnagm pie rintaihnakanid) a lah
jalany-aKnlugu rmuask,ia k utdiiald;aa jhn a ngan­
lakha mmue ngikutij(aylaalnnag-i kjnaa)rl,ea nna
jalan-ijtmauel nacne rai-bkeamruad iakjraainl an­
Nya(.A" l-A1n5'3a)m :
Shaladwaanst a lasme nanttieralsiama ptaahs
Rasulp-eNnyuapt,au rnpaa b�i y anbergs abda:
,,
,, ,,. ,,,,. ., .,., ,./
,o�IJ'l'lJ,U4-L.1�<JJ�� ��?'
., .,., ,. ., ., * .,
:Jii
��fJ)f1 �ct:�J ����, �.i_;.1l�)J 1 Li
., ,. - ., .,. .,
"SesunggBuahnnIiys ar (aYialh utdeil)ta ehrp e­ benbaer rimkaenp aAdlal daahnH arKeim udian.
cahm enja7d1gi o londgaannu ,m atakkua tne r­ Yandge mikiitaaund allaehb utaimha (bagimu)
pecamhe nja7d3gi o lonSgeamnu.a ndyida a lam dalne bbiahia kkb iatny(aA.l"- A1n5'3am):
nerakkeac ualgio lsoantguDa int.a" ny"aWkaa­n,
Kareniats ue,to iraaypna gnm ge nasiuhmaattin ya
haRia sulsuilalpasahak,gta ouhl onigtauBn?e "­
damne nciknetsaadita upnae nr samteuraebnke,ar ke­
limaeun ja"wYaabiy,ta unm ge ngiakkuutp ia da
wajiubnatnbu ekru sasheam ampmuennyyaa tukan
1
hariind iapn a rsaa hab"atku.
ketersemrearkedakiana t kaesb endaarmnae nn,g em­
Ammab a'du: balikans empeperaredmtkaaia s N aa b;Ii,b a aiqki dah,
syamraiuaptau knh lkaakr;me ennag ifkuitir man-Nya:
All�a the lmaehn ghaeknid-dekneghaenn dak
kauniqyaahd ariyah-MNuysal-itkmeairunpm e cah tl.J._,i ..'! ""'�""' � .,,,.j � ,,,,.. ��,,,.,I t p.;•1 c.' �.,. -.,,,,1 clj
_,.
belmaehn jbaedrib saegkagtioe l,o dnagmnaa nd zhab,
"Dabne repgangklaamhus emuankyeap atdaal i
yanmge musduahnmi e nidpauys aa tsua mlaa in.
(agamAal)l adha,nj anganlahb ekrcaemrua i­
Denghaainlt m ue,r emkean yepleirsiiAnhltilsa aahha t
berai(.A"ll mir an: 103)
terjpaedris elaigsakireh mabknae lpiak diat ab Allah
dasnu nnNaahb i-dNaylafa,im r -mNayna: Dia nthaartlae rpeynatnhigan rugds i segerakan
dengpaenr kianiriaa,lm aehn jelaskpaanrp aek ­epada
ngiskeukytta enm ge nlyiesseirhauila -nQu draaSnnu n­
naaht paesl aanrgadgnap ne nyimpyaannmgagen n g­
halamnegried kaapr eint juudka mne netjaapmia ah
"Kemudjiiakknaa m bue rlainan tpeenntdaanpga t
kauMmu slimin.
sesuamtaukk,ae mbalikiaakn elpaaAhdl al (aahl ­
. .
Dasriimn uin ciudulen tmuekn ghibmeprubna gai
Quradna)nR as(uslu nnahjniykkaaa)m ,bu e nar-
pertaynayndagia tnu kjeupkaapnda ar a pseemkutdea
Syi'IatshnA as yari(ySayhDi uaBahe las). iSneim oga
Shahaith- TiSrymaiaidzlki-h,A lbani p(e2m1b2i9c)a.r aLainh at
dapmaetn gemboarlainkga-no rbaenrgad kayaraling
tenthaandigin tbisa, ir ki wamyaautpd uinr adyaaltra,im s alah
kalamnegraenkk eap akdeab enjairmkaae nr,em kea­
SyaSiaklhai lm- HDialraa'll -iI,'r atHnia ydaMibatA sn 'aa laihi
renunpgekrtaann yrataann-iypnaeyiaa nnt gi daadka
waa l-Ashhab.
3