HARON OHN Fourteenth Court of Appeals MARC B

195 Pages·2014·6.92 MB·English

Justices Chief Justice
WILLIAM J. BOYCE KEM THOMPSON FROST
TRACY CHRISTOPHER
MARTHA HILL JAMISON Clerk
SHARON MCCALLY CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE
J. BRETT BUSBY PHONE [phone]
JOHN DONOVAN Fourteenth Court of Appeals
MARC W. BROWN Christopher Prine, Clerk
KEN WISE 301 Fannin, Suite 245
Houston, Texas 77002

September 17, 2014

RE: Destruction of civil case records.
Dear District and County Clerks:
Beginning December 16, 2014, the Fourteenth Court of Appeals will begin destruction of records
in civil cases that have been finally disposed of and stored for at least six years. See Tex. Gov’t Code
Ann. § 51.204(d). Prior to destruction, records requested by a district or county clerk, in accordance with
records retention schedules for records of district and county clerks, may be returned to their respective
offices. See Tex. Gov’t Code Ann. § 51.204(d) (1). Additionally, records of the appellate court
determined to be archival state records will be forwarded to the Texas State Library and Archives
Commission for preservation.
The following criteria may be considered when identifying archival state records: (1) any
landmark legal opinion; (2) any case with a high degree of inherent legal interest, including a case in
which the Texas Supreme Court granted an application for petition for review; (3) any case that involved
significant people or events; (4) any case that received a high degree of media attention; or (5) records
that, in the opinion of the Clerk or other person designated by the Court, contain highly concentrated,
unique, and valuable information unlikely to be found in any other source available to researchers.
Although the Fourteenth Court of Appeals is currently reviewing all of the cases identified for
destruction, I welcome comments from the various counties within our jurisdiction. The civil records
under consideration for destruction are the appeals and original proceedings that were finally disposed of
and stored during the calendar year of 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998, & 1999. For your convenience, a list of
cases from your county, grouped by year, for each year that a case was disposed of and stored by this
Court is attached. Please review the list of cases for both local records retention compliance and, if
desired, the archival criteria above. I would ask that special attention be given to identify those cases that
may have received a high degree of media attention in your area. Anyone who wishes to suggest that a
specific civil case should not be destroyed may contact the Clerk of the Court at
[email protected]. The deadline to contact the Fourteenth Court of Appeals is
December 16, 2014.
Thank you for your time and attention to this matter.

Very truly yours,

Christopher A. Prine, Clerk
AUSTIN (DISTRICT COURT) CASES

Final Storage Trial Court Case
Case Number Appellant Appellee County Trial Court
Date Number
14-94-01145-CV Hundl, Jr. Daniel James Nigh, Susan Gail 04/09/96 Austin County Court 7359
Oakley, Gladys M.,
Judge of County Court
14-97-00398-CV Clayton, Brenda Colene 05/07/97 Austin County Court Unknown
at Law, Austin County,
Texas
Evans, Shirley, Pfluger, First National Bank of
Joyelyn Hoppe Bellville, Darly Mertins,
Pflughaupt, Gary Individually and as
Pflughaupt, Gene Independent Executrix
Pflughapt, Marie of the Estate of James
Pflughaupt, and La Helwig, Deceased,
14-94-00325-CV 02/20/98 Austin County Court 6807
Verne Hoppe Roberts, Dottie Helwig, Brady
Individually and as Helwig, and Otto
Independent Co- Knippel as Independent
Executrix with Vivian Executor of the Estate
Hoppe of the Estate of of Irene Knippel,
Virgil Hoppe, Deceased Deceased

Page 1
AUSTIN (DISTRICT COURT) CASES

Final Storage Trial Court Case
Case Number Appellant Appellee County Trial Court
Date Number
Honorable Beck, Dan
R., Judge 155th District
14-96-00525-CV Fitts, Barbara V. 05/14/96 Austin 155th District Court 94R-095
Court, Austin County,
Texas
Evans, Ruby and King,
14-94-00979-CV Ray, Lawrence Earl 07/25/96 Austin 155th District Court 94V-133
Novella
Judge, Beck, Dan R.,
Judge of the 155th 94-0495 &94-
14-96-00730-CV Fitts, Jr., Charles Edward 08/12/96 Austin 155th District Court
District Court, Austin 0496
County, Texas
Austin County Appraisal Einkauf, Clarence, Et
14-97-00114-CV 05/30/97 Austin 155th District Court 93V-101
District Ux.
Krampitz, David H.,
Kovar, Pete and Kovar,
14-95-00586-CV Krampitz, Phillip Wayne 06/09/97 Austin 155th District Court 94V-091
Joyce
and Krampitz, H.E.
14-95-01292-CV Randle, Bert Mid Gulf, Inc. 07/07/97 Austin 155th District Court 95V-019

Page 1
BRAZORIA (COUNTY COURT) CASES

Final Storage Trial Court Case
Case Number Appellant Appellee County Trial Court
Date Number
14-96-01100-CV Norton, Adelaide Estate of Benny 02/06/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 20,313
Maurice Norton, LAW NO 1
Deceased
14-96-01246-CV Texas Department of Glasco, Kent 08/04/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,869M
Public Safety LAW NO 1
14-96-00468-CV Texas Department of William Edward 10/14/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,565M
Public Safety Repschleger LAW NO 1
14-97-00002-CV Texas Department of Mendoza, Jr., Jose 02/12/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,155G
Public Safety Salazar LAW NO 1
14-97-00450-CV Texas Department of Butler, Mickey Ray 03/27/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,472M
Public Safety LAW NO 1
14-96-01364-CV Texas Department of Peltier, IV, Mitchell E. 08/21/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,127M
Public Safety LAW NO 1
14-98-00872-CV Tejas Gas Pipeline, LLC Blanche Bertie Warren 11/03/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 24,103M
Todd, Et Al. LAW NO 1
14-97-00547-CV Texas Department of Edenton, Thomas 11/03/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22304M
Public Safety Edward LAW NO 1
14-98-00875-CV Tejas Gas Pipeline, LLC M.B. Marshall 11/03/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 24,109M
LAW NO 1
14-97-00449-CV Texas Department of Walter, Richard 12/04/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,424M
Public Safety Charles LAW NO 1
14-98-00697-CV In The Matter of B.I. The State of Texas 12/13/99 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 5937M
LAW NO 1
14-96-00153-CV Paul, Wayne A. First USA Bank 06/17/96 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 20,691G
LAW NO 2
14-97-00471-CV Seaway Pipeline Germany, Garvin H., 08/04/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,594G
Company, Arco Pipe Presiding Judge of LAW NO 2
Line Company and County Court at Law
Phillips Petroleum No. 2, and Probate
Company Court of Brazoria
County, Texas

Page 1
BRAZORIA (COUNTY COURT) CASES

14-97-00472-CV Arco Pipe Line Company Germany, Garvin, 08/04/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,594G
and Phillips Petroleum Judge of County Court LAW NO 2
Company at Law No.2 and
Probate Court of
Brazoria County, Texas
14-97-00141-CV Texas Department of Nordin, Jr., Glenn 05/29/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,276G
Public Safety Casey LAW NO 2
14-96-01099-CV Texas Department of Guajardo, Danny 06/16/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,852G
Public Safety LAW NO 2
14-98-00871-CV Tejas Gas Pipeline, LLC Design Assurance, Inc. 11/03/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 24,101-G
LAW NO 2
14-98-00876-CV Tejas Gas Pipeline, LLC Regina C. Evans, Et Al. 11/03/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 24,133-G
LAW NO 2
14-97-00242-CV Palmer, Patsy, Federal Debt 12/3/1998 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 18,618
Individually and as Management, Inc. LAW NO 2
Independent Executrix
of the Estate of
Raymond M. Palmer,
Deceased and Richard
M. Palmer
14-97-00003-CV Texas Department of Arrington, William 12/04/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,285G
Public Safety Charles LAW NO 2
14-96-01512-CV Texas Department of Monroe, James Louis 02/23/99 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,785G
Public Safety LAW NO 2
14-97-00491-CV Texas Department of Cortinas, Carol Ann 03/08/99 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,415G
Public Safety LAW NO 2
14-98-01415-CV In Re: Linda Thi Huynh 07/09/99 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 6,913G
LAW NO 2
14-99-00031-CV L.T.H. (WHC) The State of Texas 07/09/99 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 24,841-G
LAW NO 2
14-94-00834-CV Turner, Robert Somers, In Re: Estates of 01/23/96 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 18,661
Jr., Tuner, Mary & Helena Dorothy LAW NO 3
Waguespack, Cynthi Turner, Deceased, Et Al
14-96-00601-CV John Lentworth Dr. Richard Victoria 08/20/96 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,840B
#340466 and Warden Stacks LAW NO 3

Page 2
BRAZORIA (COUNTY COURT) CASES

14-94-00956-CV Smith, Rodney Wayne Webb, Victor and 10/25/96 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 20,350B
Becker, Fred LAW NO 3
14-96-01299-CV PAULA LAWRENCE, THE HONORABLE 11/12/96 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,171
R.N., JOELLA SOUTH, JAMES A. BLACKSTOCK LAW NO 3
R.N, ANGLETON-
DANBURY GENERAL
HOSPITAL, AND
MEMORIAL
MANAGEMENT
SERVICES, INC. F/K/A
MEMORIAL CARE
MANAGEMENT
SERVICES, INC.
14-95-01003-CV Hoover, Alan Hawkins, Jim 02/06/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 20,499B
LAW NO 3
14-96-00379-CV Hoover, Alan Hawkins, Jim 02/06/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 20,499B
LAW NO 3
14-96-01296-CV John Lentworth Jerry Deere, Distict 02/06/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,840B
Clerk of Brazoria LAW NO 3
County
14-94-00809-CV Pine, Robert Edward The State of Texas 02/06/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 19,369B
LAW NO 3
14-97-00131-CV McGowen, Robert S., Honorable Mills, Jerri 02/13/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,171
Guardian of the Estate Lee, Assigned Judge, LAW NO 3
of Ronald Cole County Court at Law
McGowen Ward and No. 3 and Probate
McGowen, Robert S. Court of Brazoria
and McGowen, Elisa, County, Texas
Individually
14-97-00473-CV Arco Pipe Line Company Blackstock, James A., 08/04/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,595B
and Phillips Petroleum Presiding Judge, LAW NO 3
Company County Court at Law
Number 3 and Probate
Court of Brazoria
County, Texas

Page 3
BRAZORIA (COUNTY COURT) CASES

14-97-00474-CV Seaway Pipeline Blackstock, James A., 08/04/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,595B
Company, Arco Pipe Presiding Judge, LAW NO 3
Line Company, and County Court at Law
Phillips Petroleum Number 3 and Probate
Company Court of Brazoria
County, Texas
14-97-00475-CV Seaway Pipeline Blackstock, James A., 08/04/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,574B
Company, Arco Pipe Presiding Judge, LAW NO 3
Line Company, and County Court at Law
Phillips Petroleum Number 3 and Probate
Company Court of of Brazoria
County, Texas
14-97-00476-CV Arco Pipe Line Company Blackstock, James, 08/04/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 21,574B
and Phillips Petroleum Judge of The County LAW NO 3
Company Court at Law Number
3, and Probate Court of
Brazoria County, Texas
14-96-00600-CV Doris M. Tigner City of Angleton 09/16/97 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 20,006B
LAW NO 3
14-97-00911-CV Ford Motor Company Judge Blackstock, 10/16/1997 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 16,247
James A., Probate and LAW NO 3
County Court at Law
No. 3., Brazoria
County, Texas
14-97-00624-CV Doherty, Frank, Trustee, Devaughn, Reginald 11/03/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,147B
Et Al W., Et Al LAW NO 3
14-98-00874-CV Tejas Gas Pipeline, LLC John G. Winkleman, Et 11/03/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 24,108B
Al. LAW NO 3
14-98-00873-CV Tejas Gas Pipeline, LLC Raymond Parthum and 11/03/98 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 24,105B
Carolyn Partham LAW NO 3
14-96-01511-CV The State of Texas Sledge, William L., 02/23/99 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 16,698B-1
Sledge, William Roger, LAW NO 3
Attorney-in-Fact for
Sledge, William L., The
Estate of Sledge,

Page 4
BRAZORIA (COUNTY COURT) CASES

Gladys V. and Sledge,
W. Roger, Independent
Executor
14-97-01247-CV Texas Department of Johnathan Marc 07/09/99 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,775B
Public Safety Thomas LAW NO 3
14-99-00301-CV In Re: Karam, Jerome 07/12/99 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,247&22,247-A
M. LAW NO 3
14-97-01357-CV Texas Department of Breazeale, Jimmie 12/13/99 Brazoria COUNTY COURT AT 22,790B
Public Safety Ladell LAW NO 3

Page 5
BRAZORIA (DISTRICT COURT) CASES

Final Storage Trial Court Case
Case Number Appellant Appellee County Trial Court
Date Number
14-95-00660-CV Jones, Robert Lee Doughty, D., Warden 01/29/96 Brazoria 149th District Court 94I0049
14-96-00126-CV McGowen, Robert S., May, Robert E., Judge 02/12/96 Brazoria 149th District Court Unknown
Guardian of the Estate of the 149th District
of McGowen, Ronald Court of Brazoria
Cole , A Minor County, Texas, and
Deere, Jerry, District
Clerk of Brazoria
County, Texas
14-95-01373-CV Flores, Erby #574931 Texas Department of 02/23/96 Brazoria 149th District Court 95I0017
Criminal Justice-
Institutional Division,
Et Al
14-94-00833-CV Jaxson, Richard, Inmate Safely, L., Ms. 03/11/96 Brazoria 149th District Court 94I0035
#468760 Mailroom Supervisor
14-95-00331-CV Plant The Earth Brazoswood National 06/21/96 Brazoria 149th District Court 91M1197
Corporation, a/k/a Plant Bank
The Earth, Inc.
14-95-00028-CV Karl, Sr. Gary L. Walker, Darlene 06/24/96 Brazoria 149th District Court 94I0001-2
14-94-00539-CV Benavides, Eduardo M. Texas Department of 07/12/96 Brazoria 149th District Court 94-I0008
Criminal Justice,
Institutional, Div.
14-95-01065-CV McDowell, Joyce Cox, Richard, d/b/a 07/15/96 Brazoria 149th District Court 91M1669
Red Top Restaurant
14-94-00789-CV Moore, Larry Pena, A. 08/20/96 Brazoria 149th District Court 94I0013-3
14-94-00790-CV Moore, Larry Lopez, Amparo 10/10/96 Brazoria 149th District Court 94I0013-6
14-96-01413-CV Fres Vela The Honorable Robert 01/02/97 Brazoria 149th District Court Unknown
May, Judge, 149th
District Court, Brazoria
County
14-95-00531-CV Hodgson, Monique The University of Texas 01/02/97 Brazoria 149th District Court 90M2956-1
Medical Branch at

Page 1
BRAZORIA (DISTRICT COURT) CASES

Galveston, Et Al
14-96-00354-CV Charles Bonner #560458 Tracy Williams, et. al. 02/06/97 Brazoria 149th District Court 90I0011
14-96-00802-CV Beacon National William Daniels 03/17/97 Brazoria 149th District Court 92M3231
Insurance Co.
14-96-01433-CV Stockman, Lawrence Halliburton Company 05/06/97 Brazoria 149th District Court 95M2817-1
14-96-00237-CV Terrence R. Spellmon Texas Department of 05/06/97 Brazoria 149th District Court 95I0043
Criminal Justice,
Institutional Division
14-95-00908-CV Loftin, Valerie Rice, Unruh, Reynolds 05/30/97 Brazoria 149th District Court 94M1473-1
Co.
14-95-00875-CV Martinez, Mario Thaler, Richard, 06/16/97 Brazoria 149th District Court 95I0020
Anthony J. Collins, Tina
M. Carmona, Et Al
14-94-00746-CV Schlager, Rita D. and Robert Clements, Jr., 06/23/97 Brazoria 149th District Court 91M3052
Schlager, Ronald J. Roy E. Brown, Alton C.
Todd and Brown, Todd,
Hagood & Davenport
14-96-00238-CV Horace Albert Knight Anthony W. Wiggins 12/11/97 Brazoria 149th District Court 95I0038
#287645
14-95-00341-CV Dunlap, Dwight Dow Chemical 01/08/98 Brazoria 149th District Court 93M2000
Company and Jim
Andrews
14-96-00355-CV George Childs Carl Ward, et al 01/29/98 Brazoria 149th District Court 92I0034
14-98-00364-CV In Re Billy Dale Carter 04/13/98 Brazoria 149th District Court 2858*I97
14-94-01114-CV Gomez, Richard F. Texas Department of 05/29/98 Brazoria 149th District Court 94I0032
Criminal Justice
Institutional Division
14-96-00232-CV Agency Rent-A-Car Brenda Hughes 06/16/98 Brazoria 149th District Court 92M2386
14-97-01298-CV Richard Tobias Lt. Kufeji, Et Al 10/05/98 Brazoria 149th District Court 1432I97
14-98-01054-CV Turner, Albert Adalpe, Anna, 10/27/98 Brazoria 149th District Court 96M1490
Individually and As
Next Friend of Aldape,
Miguel, A Minor
14-97-00971-CV Simmons, Alton Williams, Drew 12/04/98 Brazoria 149th District Court 96I0977

Page 2