Epea and Grammata. Oral and Written Communication in Ancient Greece

222 Pages·2001·2.939 MB·English

by  I. Worthington, Ian Worthington

EPEAAN DG RAMMATA
MNEMOSYNE
BIBLIOTCHLEACSASB IACTAA VA
COLLEGERUNT
H.P INKSTER· H.S .V ERSNEL
D.M.S CHENKEVELD· PH.S CHRIJVERS
S.RS.L INGS
BIBLIOTHECAFEA SCICULOESD ENDOS CURAVIT
H.P INKSTER, KLASSIEK SEMINAORUIDUEM ,T URFMARKT 129A,M STERDAM
SUPPLEMENDTUUCMNE TESIMTURMI CESIMUM
IANW ORTHINTGO NA NDJ OHNM ILEFSO LEY
EPEA GARANMDM ATA
EPEAAND GRAM MATA
ORALA ND WRITTENC OMMUNICATIOINN
ANCIENTG REECE
(ORALAINTDLY I TERIANCA YN CIEGNRTE ECVEO,L4 .)
EDITED
BY
IANW ORTHINGTAONND jOMHINL EFSO LEY
BRILL
LEIDE·BNO STON·K OLN
2002
This bporoikno tniae scd i rdep-eaf per.
DieD eutschBei blioth-eCkI P-Einheitsaufnalune
[MnemosynIe Supplementutn]
Mnemos:yb nieb licoltahseBscaiatc aSavu ap.p lem-eLnetiudm;e. n
Bost;Ko onl :Bn r ill
FruheSrc hriftenreihe
Teiluw..d .MTn:e mosynIeS upplements
ReihSeu pplemenztuu:Mm n emosyne
230W.o rthingItaonan n dF olJeoyh nM ile:sE peaa ndg rammata.
Epeaan gdr amm:ao traaa nlwd r itctoemnm uniicnaa ntciioGenrn ete ce
Ie db.yI aWno rthinagnJtdoo hnMn i lFeolse -yL.e id;Be ons t;Ko onl n
:B ri2l0l0,2
(Mnemosy:nS eu pplement;2u 3m0 )
ISBN9 0-0-41245-5l
Libraroyf C ongresCsa taloging-in-PublDiactaati on
LibroafCr oyn rgeCsast alogingo-niD na-tiPaasu l baslavoii claatbile
ISSN0 619-8958
ISBN9 0 104245 l5
© Copy2r0i0lyg2 hKto ninBkrilNlyV,lkLe ei deTnhN,ee therlands
Alrlig hrtess eNropv aeordftt. h piusb limcqyab treie opnro dturcaendss,lt aoitrnee dd,
ar etrsiyesvotatrelr m a,n simanin .tyfot roelymrd a rmrye aenlse,c tronic,
mechapnhioctaolcr,oe pcyooirorndt gih,nge wriwtihpsoreuwi,tro irt ten
pemrisfrsoimto hnpe u blisher.
Authortipozh aottiiootc.foneor mpi syn teorprne arls onal
usiegs r alyn Btreipdlr lo vtihdaetd
thaep profepearisra peta edi idr teToch tCelyo pyright
CleaCraennc2te e 2Rr, o 2s eDwroioSvdue 9i,1te0
DanvMAe r0s1 92U3S,A .
Feaersse u btjcoeh catn ge.
PRINTEDI NT HE NETHERLANDS
CONTENTS
Prefa0 0c 0 0e 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0v 0u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
LisotfI llustrations 1x
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
NotoensC ontribouootooooooooorooooosooo ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo XI
PARTO NE
LITERATURAER,T A,N DD RAMA
ChaptOenreE ditainndTg r anslTartaidnigtO iroanla l
EpiTch:eS ouStlha vSiocn gs Hoamnedr 3
000 000 00 o0o0 O0o0 0 00 0 00 00 00
JohMni lFeolse y
ChaptTweor RituSaple eicnEh a rGlrye eSko ng 29
00000000000000
JohF.n G arcia
ChapTtherre Teh eE vocaotfiE omno tiRoensaplo nse
inE arGlrye ePko etarnydP ainting 55
00 000 00 0 000 0 00o o0 0000 000 0 0000 00 000 00
E.Ao Mackay
ChaptFoeurr S peeAcchti snt hEev eryWdoaryl d
andi nH omeTrh:eR ebuakse Caa sSet udy 71
00 0000 0 00 0 00 00 0000 00
ElziabMeitnhc hin
ChapFtievrHe omerSiicg annsdF lashMbeumlobr y 99
RutShc odel
ChaptSeixrD ancitnhAgel phaPbeeortrf:m ative
Literoanc ytA htetS itca ge l7l
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
NialWl Sltaer
PARTT WO
RHETORIACN DS OCIETY
ChaptSeerv eEnn tertaainndDm eemnotac triDci strust:
TheA uidencAet'tsi ttuodweaO rrdasal n dW ritten
OrationrC yl acsasAlit hens 133
Oo0 00 0 00 00o o00 00 0000 0000 0 0000 00 00 000 00 00 0 00 00 0 00 00
JohSacnleh omann
VI CONTENTS
ChapEtiegrh Lti terOarcayl,ai ntdLy e,g islative
ProceidnuC rales siActahle n.s . . . . . . .. ... ..1 .4.7 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
JamesS iPck.i nger
PARTT HREE
PHILOSOPHY
ChaptNeirn eP hiloolrPo hgiyl osSoipmhpyl?i cius
ont hUes eo fQ uotati.o .n s. . . . . . . . ... 1.7 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
HanB altussen
Bibliog.r a. p.h .y . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.9 1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
Index 203
............................................................................................
PREFACE
Thivso luimsae selecotfpi aopne prrse seantt etcdho eenr fence
'EpaenaGd r ammataa:n WdOr riatlCt oemnm unicianAt nicoine nt
Greehceel'd,t hUaent i veorfMs iistsyio -uCroluUm.b.SiAia,Jn, u ne
200a0n,cd o nvebnyJe odh Mni lFeosl aenyId aWno rthinTghteo n.
coenrfenwcaesa lstohf euo rtihnw hahta bse coamb ei ensneiraile s,
which ibnJe ugla1yn99 4w heWno rthincgotnovne' nVeodi ce Into
Texatt't hUen iverosfTi atsym anAiuas,t rEaJl.Bi rai.ol fTl h e
Netheralgarnedepsdu btloi sh rseeefrlepeeacdpt efeorrdms t hat and
subseqcuoeenrnfetn acneidsn 1, 9 96V oiItcnoeTe x tO,r aalniLrydi tcye ra
iAnn iceGnrte (eecdeib tyWe odr thinagptpoenaI)rnJ eudl.1y 99 6A nne
Mackcaoyn ve'niSegdn sO roafla itt yUt'nh iev eorfNs aittaSylo ,u th
Africaan,di n1 999S ginqfs O rlairyT,hO era lTr aditainiodtn Is nflu ence
int he aGrnede kR Woomrla(dne dibtyMe adc yk)aw asp ubliTshheend .
iJnul1y99 8JanWeatt scoonn ve'nEepado nsLd o goast' U tnhiev ersity
ofW ellinNgetwoZ nel,aa nSdpe;a kiVnogl uOmraelsia.ryn L di teirna cy
thGer eaenkRd o maWnor l(de dibtyJe adn Weatt swoansp) u bliisnh ed
2001T.h utsh,pe r esbeonoitkVs o lu4mi ent hOer alaintLdyi teracy
serIinJe usl.2y 0 0C2h,r istMoapchkewirie lc lo nvtehnfieef tmhe et­
inagtt hUen iveorfsM ietlyb ouArunset,r( awlitithahte h em'eOr al
TradiatnidMo antse rCioanlt eaxntda' tt) h,si tsa tghese i xttoh ,b e
conveneMda rgbayFl iintk elibsse erftrog T ,e Alv iivn2 002.
Onefa etuorfte h Oer alaintLdyi tesraecriyist e hsee m phaosni s
plenotfty i mferod iscussioantf,e erna octh opbnaualptlye sd rou r ­
intgh ceo enrfengceen eraanldol nsy o ceixaclu rsTihoeMn iss.s ouri
coenrfenwcaesn od ieffre-notv etrh ceo urosfe w ae etkw,o dozen
papesrosm,pe r ecircbuysl cahtoefldora,mr h sa lfd oaz ceonu ntries
werper eseantt eaadvn e roafgf ei vpeed ra yA.n othfaeetru hraes
beetnh aei orfg enufiirenned lienxehsisbb iyat lealdt tenmdaeke­s,
inag p eercftrleyl aaxnedcd o nviavtimaols pFhuetruemr.ee ei tngs
arlei kteolb yen od ieffrent.
WorthinagntdFo onl gerya utlelafyc knowltehsdeug pep (obrott h
moraaln d, cieasilpmlepyo rtmaonnttea,r oyf) the Departments of
HistColrays,sS itcuadli es,a nEAdnr gHtli isstahon,rAd yr chaeology,
thCee ntferor StuidnOi reasTl r adiDtiro.Rni ,c haSrcdh wartz,
Deaonf Ctohlel oefAg reta sn dS cieDnrc.e ,B radyP rDoevaotsotn ,
Vlll PREFACE
of tUhnei veorfsM iitsys ouri-CaonldDu rmR.bi icah,Wa radl lace,
Chanceolftl hoUern iverosfMi itsys ouri-CWoel aurmaebl isao.
grautlte ofa ltlh pea rticaittp haceno tensrf enwcheom adiets uch
as ucfcluea snsed nojyabelvee annttd,o woiuvre s WTorratchyi ngton
andA nne-Mariweh opF roolveiyid,ne tde llaencdpt ruaaclts iucpa­l
porItn.a dditwieow no,u lldi kteot hatnhkce o ntritbout thoirss
boowkh o qsuoi crkelsyp otnodW eodr thoinn'rgset quaensdtd si d
noatb uhsiemt omou cha,n da lJsuol iDaena haln dM ichKileeli n
SwormaitnB kr ill.
Threneo t(es1a:)l d la tienst hbeo oakr BeC u nleostsh erwise
indic(a2tG)ei dv.et nh atthc eo ntriibntu htbioosro slk i ivneN orth
AmeriAcuas,t raanldEi uar owpeeh ,a vael lobwoetAdhm eriacnadn
Englsipsehl lriantghtseh rat nr yitnoig m poosnees pelslyimsnt.ge
(3D)e psittehi en evictraibtlioecfi i nscmo nsiwseht aevnaecl yl,o wed
thoasuet horsp rewftheootr r anslGirteeenrkaa mteers a thtehra n
anglitchietzmhe le u xuorfdy o itnhgi s.
IaWno rthington JohMni lFeosl ey
DepartomfHe instt oryC entferorS tudiOersa Tlir na dition
University ofD epartmoefCn ltass sical
Missouri-ColumSbtiuad& i Eensg lish
May2 010 UniveorfsM iitsys ouri-Columbia
LISOTF I LLUSTRATIONS
E.AM.A CKAY
Figure 1
Proto-aAmtpthiobcry ta h Peo p1hyemPoasi nEt1eeru,Ms uisse um.
PhotogcroappyhrD ieguhtts Acrhcehsa eo1IongsitsAictthhuee(tsnn eg.
no. E5l4e4uD)set.ia sfio rlm t hnee cOkd:y ssaenutdsw oof h imse n
put tohueety oef P oplhyemos.
Figu2r e
Attbilca ck-afimgpuhrobery ta h e Paoiftn htVeea rt iMcoaunr ner,
Vatic1a568n1 D.e atiolfr evesrcseenM ee:n elraeogsa Hienlse ne.
Photogcroauprhot fet shMyee tropMoluisteauonmfA rtN,e wY ork,
reopdrucbeykd i npde rmisstihDoein r eozfGi eonneerM aolneu,m enti
MuseeiG allPeornitei Vfiactiiec,a n.
Figu3r e
Attbilca ck-afmipghuorbreyGa r ouEp, Lond2o0n5O .bB v seer:
thdee aotfhP raimoPsh.o togcroauprhto efts hyTe r ustoefte hse
BritMiusshe um.
Figu4r e
Attibcl ack-afmipghuobrryEea x ekias, Bou5l5o8Ogb.nv ee-rssuer -mer
sceAniea:ps r epatroce osm msiuti cPihdoet.o gcroauprhot fet shye
Chateau-BMouusleoeg,n e-sur-mer.
NIALLS LATER
Drawibnytg h aeu thor.