Dignity in Adversity: Human Rights in Troubled Times

311 Pages·2011·4.84 MB·English

by  Seyla Benhabib

SeylBae nhabib
DIGNI1Y
NAOVERSI1Y
HumanR ightisnT urbulTeinmte s

Tot hMee moroifJe oshE n.S mith
anDda ivdE .A pter
DIGNITIYN A DVERSITY
HumanR ightisnT roublTeidm es
SeylBae nhabib
polity
Copyri©g hSety laB enhab2i0b1 1
Ther igohftS eylaB enhabtiobb e i dentiafisAe ud tohro ft hiWso rkh asb eeans seritne d
accodrancew itth hUeK C opyrigDhets,i gannsd P atenAtcst1 988.
Fisrtp ublishedi n2 011b yP olity Press
PoliPtrye ss
65B rdigeS treet
CambriCdBg2le U RUK,
Poliyt Perss
350M ainS treet
MaldeMAn, 02148U,S A
Allr ihgtsr eservEexdc.e pfto trh eq uotatoifos hno rpta ssafgeotsrh ep urpoosfec riitcsim
andr evienwop, a rto ft hipsub lictioanm ayb ere produced, storienda retriseyvsatle omr,
transmittde,i na nyf ormo rb ya nym eanse,l ectrmonecihacn,i c, aplhotoconpgyr,ie cording
oro therwisew,i thotuhtep riorp ermissoifto enh p ubhleirs.
ISBN-1937:8 -0-7456-5442-3
ISBN-1937:8 -0-67-4554 43-0(pb)
A catalorgeuceo frodrt hiboso ki sa vailafrboml et heB ritLiisbhr ary,
Typeseitn1 0.o5n 1 2p tS abon
byT oppaBnes t-setP remedLiiam ited
Prinatnedbd o unidnG raetB ritabiytn h eMP G BookGsr oup
Thep ublihserh asu seidt bse setn daevourst oe nsutreh atthU eR Lsfo re xterwneabls ites
refertroei dnt h sib ooka rec orreacntda c itvea tt het imoef g oitnogp res.s Howevetrhe,
publishhaesnr o r espnosibilityf otrh ew ebsiatnedsc anm aken og uaranttheaeat s iwtiel l
remain liovret hathte conteinsot r w ilrlem ain apporpraite.
Evereyffo rth asb eenm adeto tracalelc opyrihgohltd ebrusti, fan yh avbeee ni nadvertently
overlootkheepd ub lisherw ilbelp leasteoid n cluadneyn ecessary icnar neyd siutbss equent
reprionret d ition.
Foef urthienrf ormaotniP oonl ity,o urvw iesbisti wtwew:. politybooks.com
CONTENTS
Preface vii
Acknowledgments X
1. IntroductCioosnm:o politawniitshmo uItl lusions 1
2. FromT he DialecotfiE cn lghitenmentto
TheO rgiinso fT otalitariaTnhiesomd:o Ard orno
andM axH orkheimientr h eC ompanyo fH annah
Arendt 20
3. InternatiLoanwaa ln dH umanP luraliintt hye
Shadowo fT otalitariHaanninsamAh:r endatn d
RaphaeLle mkin 41
4. AnotheUrn iversalOins tmh:e U nitayn dD iversity
ofH umanR ights 57
5. IsT herae H umanR ightto D emocracBye?y ond
InterventiaonndiI snmd ifference 77
6. TwiligohfSt o vereiyg onrtt heE mergenocfe
CosmopoliNtoarnm sR?e thinkCiintgi zenisnh ip
VolatTiilmee s 94
v
CONTENTS
1. ClaimiRnigg htAsc rosBso rderIsn:t ernational
HumanR ightasn dD emocratSiocv ereignty 117
8. DemocratEixcc lusiaonndsD emocratIitce rations:
DilemmaosfJ usMte mbershainpd P rospecotfs
CosmopoliFteadne ralism 138
9. TheR eturonf P olitiTchaelo logTyh:e S carfA ffair
inC omparatiCvoen stitutPieornsaple ctive
inF rancGee,r manayn dT urkey 166
10.U topiaan dD ystopiinaO urT imes 184
Noteasn dR eferences 196
Index 285
Vl
PREFACE
AruonSde pte1m8b2,e0 r0a 1l,m aod setc aadgIeoc ,r osWsheidt ney
AveniunNe e wH aveCno,n necwtiitmchyu1 t4,-a y-reodladghu ter,
travferloiomnu gr htooauR seeCd r ocsesn ttoge irbv leo foodtrh e
victainmrdse scoufte hrTeswi nW orTlowd er9s0m ilaewsa. y As I
gaev mnya mSee,y Bleanb hiatbot, h neu rsaet tienn sdhafenr coez,e
foarm ome"neBtn:- bHi"ab-wastHn a'bainAb r bainca m?"e Who
wats hliasd wyi thf oreaicgctn"e, s nhsee emteobd et hiinnkg,
a
"cmoinignt og ibvleoo d?"
Myd uagh,wt heorn otetdh neu rshs ees'itiamtmieodniu,an tdeelry­
stoodI w tahbsae tia nsgs eassas neA dr aobra M uslainmsd,h e
squemeyzh eanddi ns oliitdIyca .rol udn ohte lfepel itnhga,t early
eveniinCn ogn nectthimacytgu ets,to ufsrl oei dawriittthhvy ei ctims
of9 /11a ndt hfier eg-hfitearnsdp oelmieconf N ewY orCki ty
wanso wta ntaendda ,si ttu rnend ontoe uet:ds, e tdduenotfYs a le
Univearnsodit thyse crh ohoaladsl ryer audshteotd hR ee dC ross
banakcsr NoeswsH aveann,ad c tu,ta hlbell yobonadk wse rwee ll
stocked.
Nevheersltses,oe mthiinnm gea ch.Te hdem oroaftl h sitso irsy
noatob udti rsicmianitoang ianMsitd dElaset er,Mn uelsrismosr· ,
ArabA mearnircse,ta hlo uigiths R .ah etri,it as b otuhtcem o pelxity
anmdu ltioplfii dceintttyiow t hiicemhsy n amtee stbiufiwteh si,c h
bureaiuaccd rmaitnissthroarttsiih naoa nnin ndacirsnegsleyct uirzied
worplodtl iiecnavli ernortne mdutcoue nde quisviogocnfadal lag sne r
duritnhsgeo -lcla"edwa ro nt er.r"To hrel ayda tt hRee dC ross
statciodoun nlo htva ek nonwt hIaw ta asS ephaJredwbi ocri nn
Istawnhbouslere,al ikensotwa nn cewsatsco arl le"dJ abc Iobn­
Hab"if br,otmhc ei otfyZ amoirnSa p aainnwd,h odsseec eanndts
werRea biabsn pdr oemnimtne mbeorfaJs e wicsomhmu nifitriysn t
vii
PREFACE
Spaainn tdh einnSl aonaincGdaa lliiAp.co cortdosi onmhgei sctaolr i
rercdowsh,e mny a ncesttroibreusdfti a lteodp eurasdCeh ristian
atuhortiopt eiretmshi et Jsetwiasny tSotp haeilyni,t,k h eo usands
int hpaetr iloetdfos,t e reekf iuntg heOe t toEmmaipnr. e1
Islfaotmrh ewma s anr oetl iogfi owna jri habanudadtr eligion
oft olertahrnaects ep etchtee adJn egdwr sa nttheetdmh "eir gohft
hospti,yti"aKn la insst e'nasnend,o o tn lbcyea utshee y "wepeorpel e
oft hbeo o"kn ,amleyt,hT eor awhh,i Icshl aalmnog,w itthhN ee w
Testmaenatc,ok wnledagse idnbh geo lCye.ri tnatlyhh,ei stooftr hye
Jewosft hOet tomEamnp ihraes epxietrsi eonfc edsi scrimination,
perujdicoep,ep srsianoednx ,c luYseiwtoh enIn.r eaadob u/t'f aiafr
duf uolartdh sec aarfaffi- rt heartu pitnFe rda nwcheeFn r ench
-
atuhorbinatnieMeduss lgiimrf olrmsa ttendpuilbncigs chowoiltsh
thehiera ds caonvadeb roteuhdt"e,u t rboarbn a rstomiie seil"ie ns
TurkeIyt ,h ionfmk y o wng randmoatnahdue nrTtsh se.cy o vered
anudn covtehreheiadrii rnm ucthh sea emw aya st heMiurs lim
neighboIra sl sod iotdfOh. rti ohndkoJ xe wiwsohm ewnh ow ear
wigisnp uibpcll aicBner so okQluyeneJ,ne sra,eul msa,sw e alslP aris
anLdo nodnA.n dIa sk",aT urkis?h-""J Ae wJeTwuri?ks""h A
SpehardJiecgw r oiwnugp aiM nul sim-omrtaiycj uont"r?"yA c hild
ofA ttausrR kep'ubc?l"Wih adto eisat l mle a?n
Theer upotfpi oloinat Ilis clianmt o pwoloirtalifdctS see rp tember
1,12 010,h atsh rtuhsetas psee cotfms y b iogyr,wa hpihIch ha d
consrdei odfep riviamtpeoo rntli yn,tt oh eoarlae ntdpio clitical
debeasct nocertnhi"enida gel ctoifEc nl igmhetn"eat nntdh Jee wish
expeeri,in etnaectrinolnaaawnl td h Heo locIasulsiatncm, o ntempo­
raEruyr oapned, m tehaen oifcn ogen mtopryac rosmloipitosamn.
Thee ssays icnto hlvilosel cutwmehedi, wc ehr ew rititnte hne
perfirood2m 0 0t6o2 01d0o,c umtehntitrs a jyeT.c htecoyort ninue
thper eocjotfsd iscoeutrhasineccd smo muinctairvaet itoyan dna li
feredowmh,i chha evo Iut liinn evda riwooursk s tsheieran lcye
1990bsy,e xntdneigt heimn tthoe r atoiefnlr elgc aosmloiptoanism
anrde cweonrtpl odl itical events.
Att hcee notfemr u ccho nptoermaprolyic tadili scoiustr hsee
cocnepotf" uhmarni g"ht:th sejiuirsfi tcatthieoinr; t hsrece olpae­;
tionosfph hiipol pochsaialc cnotousfr igthoit nsnt aetridocenlaalr a­
tioanntsdoi netrnathiuomnraainlg l hatawsn, td h ediirv earcsriotsys
constiatnuldte igtoarnlais ndo sit.
Thefl oolwincgh apdtiesrcsu spsh iltohsaeon pdph olyi toifc s
humarni gbhyot fsf ears iynsgtt eiamcca coouftn htep ilcrae within
thper eocjotfd iosuscree thainccdsmo municraattilivioeTtn hyae.y
alesxoa mriingeah gtasit nhbseat c kgroofu ancndhg cinogn ceptions
Vlll
PREFACE
ofc itizienEn usrhoiippnpe ra,ct ui,la asar c onsnecqoeufM e usilm
migornaa,tn itdh elyo oaktc n oteinotduesab tseicsne S epmtbee1r1 ,
2001s,mo eo fw hidcihs mdiesmsaf nodhrsum anri gahshty sp ocriti­
cajlui sfitcaftoi"roh nuasmn iitaanirn"t eornvaset,bn etsiatnn,de o­
imrpieavleinsttou fgr leoscb aapli taawtlo irsBsmutc,t.o nsraitdieons
ofr igchatnsnb oeet n teritnadienpeedno dfte rnaotnrlsmyfa toifo ns
stasvtoeegr netiTyo.d atyht,ee nsbieotnwste heen chsatnagotifun sg
stastoeevr eiignin ntrtyne atiloaanwna tdlh neor mtaiivdee oafl a
demoicacrllayst e-lgvfoernpienogpa lrteeh seo cueor fm ucha rci­
monFyo.sr o mien,nt aetriloanuwan ld ermdienmeosc sroaevtri­c
eigfntooyrt; h -earnsIdc oumnyste almofn tgh e-mi t necniehtsa.
Mya iimn t hbioso ikst o pelxotrheci mosp lleaxn adpsaecn tdo
stiuahtuem arni gdhitssc woiutrahsv iein s oifdo enm ocirtaetriact ive
poli.t ics
IX