Difference and Givenness: Deleuze's Transcendental Empiricism and the Ontology of Immanence (Topics in Historical Philosophy)

293 Pages·2008·2.07 MB·English

by  Levi R. Bryant

TopiicnHs i storical Philosophy
GenerEadli toDras viKdo lb
JohMnc Cumber
AssociEadtiet Aorn thoJn.Sy t einbock
DIFFERENCEA ND
GIVENNESS
DeleuzTer'asn scendental Empiricism
andt he OntoolfoI gmym anence
LevRi.B ryant
NorthwestUenrinv ersity Press
EvanstIolnl,i nois
Northswteern University Press
www.unprensosrw.tehstern.edu
Copyr©i 2gh0t0b 8yN orthweUsntievrenPr rsiePtsuysb .l i2s0h0e8d. r iAglhlt s
reseedr.v
Prinitne dUt nhiet Setda otfeAs m erica
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
LibroafrC yo ngrCeastsa loging-iDna-tPau blication
BryantR,. Levi
Differeanncdge ie vnne:sD se leutzresa'cnse ntdaeelnm piriacnids mt he
ontoloofig mym ane/nL ceevR i.B ryant.
p. -cm(.T opiinhc iss toprhiiclaols ophy)
Inclubdiebsl iogrraeepfrheincacaneldis n dex.
ISB-N1937:8 --1800214-52(-lc3o t:h aplakp.e r)
ISBN-0I8-01:02 14-52(-lc1o t:h aplakp.e r)
ISB-N1937:8 -1001--85244-(7p b:ka .l pka.p er)
ISBN-0l-1O810:- 5244-(8p b:k .ap lakp.e r)
l.D eleuGziel,l1 e9s2,5 -129.E9 m5p.i ric3i.Is mmm.a ne(nPchei losophy)
IT.i tIlIeT..il t:eD eleutzrneas'cse nadlee mnptiriacnitdsh omen toloofgiym ma­
nence.S erIiNIeoIsr.:t hweUsntievrentr ospiiitnych si stoprhiiclaolys .o ph
B24305.4DB4729008
1464'0.942-dc22
2007043985
i§ Thep apuesre idnt hpiusb licmaetesitt ohnme i nimruemq uireomfte hnet s
AmeriNcaatni oSntaaln dfaorrI dno frmatSicoine -nPceersmaneonfPc aep er
forP rinLtiebdr Maartye rAiNaSlZIs3 ,9 .48-1992.
Differenncoedt i ivsey r.Ds iivtersgiitnvy,eb uits fe driefncteh abitys
whicthhg ei nvi egsi nv,et habty whtihcgehi viegsni vaesdn i evrse.
-GilDleelse uDziffeeer,n acenR dep etition

Contents
Preface ix
LisotfA bbreviations xiii
Introduction 3
Empiricainsdmt heS earfcohtr h eC onditions
ofR eaElx perience 15
2 BergsonIinatnu iatnidoI nn terDniaflf erence 49
3 TranscendeEnmtpailr icTihseIm m:a goef T hought
andt he"P henomenoloofgt yh"eE ncounter 73
4 FirMsotm enotf t heE ncountTehreS: e ntiendum 92
5 SeconMdo menotf t heE ncountTehreM: e morandum 102
6 ThirMdo menot ft heE ncountTehreC: o gitandum 135
7 OvercomSipnegc ulaDtoigvmea tiTsimm:e
andt heT rnascendeFnitealld 175
8 IndividuTahteiG oenn:e soifsE xetnsities
andt heO ther-Structure 220
Conclusion 263
Notes 267
Bibliography 271
Index 275

Preface
Thiiss b oaoo knD eleIunpz aer.t airic,itu s lb oao oknD eleumzetea'psih cyss
whicmha kensor eefrentcohe i est hipcosl,i otria cess,t hIetitsn i octs .
ab ook Doenl eaunzdeG uattNaorrii si. t b oao k on SBpuimneo,z a,
NietzosrBc ehreg,s Ido onn .os te etkod emornasttteh Daetl eiursze ea lly
aB ergsovniitaainlnd i isstg uNiosrde oI. s eetkos how Dheolwe iusz e
reaalt lhyi nokfae crt ainvdep assfiorvceeI sd .o naobto,av els le,et ko
make caonmym eonntD e luez'ecso llraabtwoiovrewk ist Ghu attaanrdi
how theser epmriegdsheetpn atr tourcr oeinsnt uatoifho inessa rlier
worIkn.f cati,no rdteoar d equaetneglaiygn se u cahp rjocetiw to uld
firbste ensesctaord yos omethingt ows hiaImt i alamat rt emphteirneg.
Rateh,rt hper esveonltu smeee tkoss p esaikm palnydi na ni nofrmed
waya bowuhta Dte lemuezaen bsy" trcaennsdaelen mtpiriicnih sims"
tweoa rmlays terpDiiffeeercnecasen R dep etiatnidTo hnLe o goifSc e nse.
In wfholalto wsse etIkod emosntrtahtaDete leutzrea'nss cenden­
taelm piriactitsemmt poot vse rctohmoeep posibtewiteoencn o ncepts
andi ntiuointnso,e asnidsa isthtehsahitas cs,h aractmeorsiotzft e hde
histoprhyi loofsa onpdwh hyi ch faorrmit sheaess sumpotfai fi onni te
sujbcetw hosree cievpititscy o cneviedo fa sp assIinv e.e xectuhtiisn g
prjocetIh avael ssoou gthodt e terhmoiwnD ee leiuaszb elt eoa viodfla l­
inign tcor itiocfbi esimnssg p ealc autdiovgem aatnidhs otwt hseu jbcet
must rebteh oiungi htrtse latitoonb sehiinCpgo .tnr atrhye,tn o, the
smoewhsatta ndpairucdrto ef D eleuwzhei,ct hr ehaitossn tolaosg ya n
empiriIch iasvsmeo, u gthopt r esaeh nytp etri-ornaalisth ivse rsion of
thougchoten,xt tualiitz tiiennrg om fs debtahtasetus r roculnads sical
rationbaulatil ssGmoe rmaind ealaises xme mpliinft ihfieegd u roefs
Kanta nSda lomMoani moTnh.ih san so bte eonu otfa d estiorp er esent
yeatn ot"hmeorn stvreorussi"Do enl eoubfzubete, c atuhspeer obl­emat
icssu rrounGdeirnmgai nd ealainsdrm a tionsatlriumscemak s c losest
tot hogsoev ernDienlge upzrejo'cesto fa t rnascenadlee mnptiricism
ands eemteodb est ehxipesln agiang emendtife frweiintacthla lculus
thaits osfoti egnn oirnet dr eatsmo efDn etleutzheo'usgI hnt .s hiofr t,
Deleiuaszb elt eod epaforrmtt hpeh ilosoofrp ehpyrn etsaetion charac­
teribzyte hdpe r imoafcty hc eo ncetphtet,nh iibsse cahuesd ei osvcers
ix
x
PREFACE
intelliigni btaihelesi tthiyet ltsfiie,cnt hvee rfyba riocft hgei nv,ei n
the fooftr hmde i fefrentoifpa elrsc epDteiloendu.oz ees snomo utc h
givuesa w ayo fm edaititnhgre e labteitwoene tnhu en ivearnsdta hle
particbuuldtai rs,p ewnisttehhs pe r oblaelmt og.eI tnth heicrso nnec­
tioIna ,ma blteop rovaij duset ificoafth iiposrn jo cett hat mnaekeed
nor eefrentcoe a poorle itthiibccasss oenda p referfeondrci fefe r­
encoev eird eintDtye.l euezteh'aisnc dsp oliftolilcosw -trliygr-hofm
hiosn tgoyln,oo tth ree rvseDee.l etuhzieno kfhs i msaesl fih nasgvo lved
av ertyr aditainodcn earnlatp lr oblientm h hei stoofpr hyi lpohsayon d
proceteodd rsat wh ceo nsequoeftn hcsieossl utIli eoaniv.tte o rmeya d­
ertsod ecide wehmepthhaesriD zeilnegud zeebt'tost hinkseurcashs
DesacrtLeesi,b Knainzat,n, dM aimodno enso ptr omvoer iel luamti­n
intgo h is teaxd ti stchuaosnfsh iitsoh no utghhatrt e lhieevasi olnyh is
debttoE ngleimsphi ricism.
Imti gshet esmt ratnoeg mep hastihzatethi iassb oooknD eleuze
whetnh ciasbn e c laerdliy scefrornme dtv heer y otfti htbelo eoH ko.w ­
evegri,v tehnse t andiamradgo efD eleuiziteis ,m preattihvaeIdt o s o.
Too oftietin sa ssumtehdat th nea me"sD eleaunzd"e D"e leaunzde
Guat"t aariridee ntaincdca albn e u seidn tenrgcehaya1.b lTqhuee stion
ofw hethoernr o sti gnitfriaconarsnmfta ttiaoknpesl aicne etnhecn o­u
teorf t hetsweoi ndividnuoaetlv se rnai iss Tehdic.so nisttuatb ees­
traoyfat lh sei unlgaroifDt eyl eutzheo'usag shw te lalst haotfD eleuze
anGdu attMaorroiev.e Dre,l euinzsei tshtacsto inntuomuusl tiplicities
chanignke i nd wdhiievdneW de.m ight ecqluaaitlmhl ayt cthhaenyg e
ink ind wnheewdn i mensairoaend sd etdot hemT.os imype lquate
"Deleuze""D eewulizatenh dG uattiastr oii "g notrheif usn damental
principle tboae l loognigmciu-nlogtf i plUincaibttlioeae dse.q uately
deawli tshu ccho mpliesxsi une sst phaeoc faes inegslyse,Ia t huosp ted
tor estricttoD emlyesuetzlhefo' usg ht.
Byc ornatst,r jeoais nodane emr i ghojtb ectott reatthinena gm e
of Delaesau zuietn pyoi, ntionutgt h atthv ea ritoeuxsbt yhs i ma lone
.d ispladyif efvreesrntyty alneds conHcoewrenvases.rh ,oI p teos hoiwn
the coofu rtbshoeio tskh ,ai rsg umfelanlptsr eyw htaIowt i llalt ceartl hle
empirfilacliaiscntty h aiittn divitdhuawatht iecsh bteoDl eolnegubszy e
theem pirtiecxmatalsr kbeydh insa maen d nowth abbtey l otnoDg es- .
)
leuzsetl'yeDs.e lehuizmes wealfsfon do fp ointoiutnthg ae tv enatrnseo t
individbd yu attihened ivitdhuabatel lso ntgh etbmou, rt a thtehrai tn di­
viduaarliesn ddiuvaitbeytd h eev entthsba tea fltlh eImn. tchoinsn ection
Ia me ntiirnae glrye emenBta dwiioctulh'a tsih ma" tD eleaurzreia vte s
concueappltr oductiIo nwso uutnlhhdiae ttsa tqiunagllaiysmfy o notonous,
composavi enrpgya rtirceugliaomrfee m phaosrai lsm oisntf irneipite­et
tioonfa l imirteepde rotfoc iornec eapst swa,esa lv li rtuvoasriicaot fi on
names, wuhnidwcehhra i tts h ourgehmta eisnnsste iaildleyn .t"i2ca l