!"#$%"$&'#()*+(,&-"+("./"0&"*'"1! 2./,30&*4(")0,5('%&,+%33+($")'%"0(*)00)$&-"#6("./"0&"*'"6( &*+&-&+7),&$5()*+(/0)'$&'"(&*($%"()"#$%"$&'(+"#&4*(38(,")0*&*4()*+( $")'%&*4("*-&03*9"*$#:! "!#$%%&'()($*+!%,-.$((&/!-0! 12)!3$%4&25!671/! 8*'!(9&!):)'/!*;! #*<(*'!*;!=9$4*%*>90! !;#$0)'$! ( !"#$%"$&'#()*+(,&-"+("./"0&"*'"1(2./,30&*4(")0,5('%&,+%33+($")'%"0( *)00)$&-"#6("./"0&"*'"6(&*+&-&+7),&$5()*+(/0)'$&'"(&*($%"()"#$%"$&'(+"#&4*(38( ,")0*&*4()*+($")'%&*4("*-&03*9"*$#( ( ( D(!$%!(9&!'&%>*+%$-$4$(0!*;!&)'40!<9$4/9**/!(&)<9&'%!(*!()E&!<*+('*4!*;!(9&! )&%(9&($&<$;$<)4405!$+! :)0%!(9)(!:$44!&+9)+<&!(9&!<)>)<$(0!)+/!&;;&<($2&+&%%!*;!(9&!4&)'+$+F!)+/! (&)<9$+F!(9)(!()E&%!>4)<&7!G*:&2&'5!(9&!:)0!(9)(!(9$%!$%!$/$*%0+<')($<)440!)+/! %,-H&<($2&40!,+/&'()E&+!-0!>')<($($*+&'%!9)%!+*(!-&&+!$+2&%($F)(&/!)%!)+0! >)'($<,4)'!;*<,%!*;!<)%&!%(,/07!I9$%!%(,/0!(9&'&;*'&!%&&E%!(*!<*+('$-,(&!(*!*,'! E+*:4&/F&!)+/!,+/&'%()+/$+F!*;!(9$%!)'&)!*;!>')<($<&!-0!$44,.$+)($+F!(9&!4$2&/! &J>&'$&+<&!K!>)%(!)+/!>'&%&+(!K!*;!)!>)'($<$>)+(!%).>4&!*;!&)'40!<9$4/9**/! &/,<)(*'%7!='$+<$>)4405!(9&!L,)4$()($2&!(9&.&%!(9)(!)'&!&J>4*'&/!)'&!(9&!>&'%*+)4! %(*'$&%5!)<<*,+(%5!>&'%>&<($2&%5!*-%&'2)($*+%!)+/!/&%<'$>($*+%!MMM!-*(9!*;!(9&! >)'($<$>)+(%!)+/!(9&!'&%&)'<9&'!MMM!*;!/&<$%$*+MMM.)E$+F!>'*<&%%&%!)+/!(9&!:)0%! (9&%&!)'&!.)+$;&%(&/!$+!>')<($<&7!N$(9!(9$%!>)'($<,4)'!;*<,%5!(9$%!'&%&)'<9! <*+('$-,(&%!(*!&)'40!<9$4/9**/!(&)<9&'!&/,<)($*+!(9'*,F9!)!L,)4$()($2&! 9$F94$F9($+F!*;!(9&!2)'$&($&%!*;!O:)0%!*;!:*'E$+FP!)+/!-0!$44,.$+)($+F!/$.&+%$*+%! *;!(&)<9&'!%,-H&<($2$(0!:9&+!<*+%$/&'$+F!(9&!/&%$F+!*;!4&)'+$+F!)+/!(&)<9$+F! &+2$'*+.&+(%7! "+!$.>*'()+(!(9&*'&($<)4!4&+%!*;!(9&!'&%&)'<9!9)%!-&&+!(*!)2*$/!)+0! &2)4,)($*+!*;!(9&!&J>&'$&+<&!*;!(9&!>)'($<$>)+(%!)F)$+%(!)!>'&MMM/&(&'.$+&/5! O*-H&<($2$%(P!)+/!'&$;$&/!+*($*+!*;!!"#$%#&!"#!'($-,(!(*!>)0!'&%>&<(!(*!(9&!:)0%!(9)(! &)<9!>)'($<$>)+(!&+F)F&%!:$(9!!"#$%#&!"#!'($)%!)!%,-H&<($2&!<*+<&>(!)+/!;'*.!(9&! :*'4/!)+/!(9&!$..&/$)<0!*;!(9&$'!4$2&/!&J>&'$&+<&!)+/!,+/&'%()+/$+F7!I9&!;*<,%! *;!(9&!'&%&)'<9!$%!(9&'&;*'&!(*!,+<*2&'!:9)(!(9&!)&%(9&($&<$;$<)440!*+!9*:!(9&0!'&4)(&! (*!)+0!*-H&<($2&!(9&*'0!*'!>9$4*%*>9$<)4!%0%(&.!*;!."%!$/++0$%#&!"#!'($0#&'/*$'&1$ I9$%!)>>'*)<9!$%!<*+%$/&'&/!$.>*'()+(!)+/!)>>4$<)-4&!(*!)+0!$.>'*2&.&+(!*;! (&)<9&'!&J>&'$&+<&!$+!F&+&')45!)%!$(!F$2&%!>'$.)<0!(*!4$2&/!&J>&'$&+<&!$+!<*+(&J(7! D.>*'()+(405!*%--%!'2#$)+/!%-!&334%�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a! L&*+(9)/# .............................................................................................................. IM! D2<>?AB(I ............................................................................................................... IN! <%)/$"0(I ................................................................................................................. NN! ?*$03+7'$&3*($3($%"(D$7+5 .................................................................................... NN! D/&+($;$<)($*+!*;!(9&!'&%&)'<9!>'*-4&. ....................................................... ?C! I9&!4&)'+$+F!&+2$'*+.&+(!bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb77b7?B! I9&!'&%&)'<9!<*+(&J( .................................................................................... ?_! <%)/$"0(N ................................................................................................................. OM( >%"(P7"#$(830(#$305HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH:OM! I9&!L,&%(!;*'!%(*'0!K!&+/&)2*,'$+F!(*!($/0!(9&!-&F$++$+F%c ..................... U1QIDV3!8VgW ......................................................................................................... BA! <%)/$"0(O ................................................................................................................. QN! !"#$%&'()*+')*+(/"0#3*),()"#$%"$&'# ............................................................... QN! U(*'0$+F!*,'%&42&% ........................................................................................ Bd! 6&.*'0!I)4E!bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb7Ba! ";'$<)!)+/!(9&!O-$'(9!*;!)&%(9&($<%P ............................................................... Bf! 3)(,'&!/$)'0 .................................................................................................. _C! <%)/$"0(R ................................................................................................................. SN! G")0*&*4("*-&03*9"*$#6(")0,5('%&,+%33+()*+("*-&03*9"*$),()"#$%"$&'#(::SN! I9&!%$F+$;$<)+<&!*;!)&%(9&($<%!)+/!(9&!4&)'+$+F!&+2$'*+.&+( .................. ad! I9&!$.>*'()+<&!*;!)&%(9&($

Aesthetics and lived experience

Similar Aesthetics and lived experience