Judge Archer

46 Pages·2009·0.7 MB·English

Judge Archer

The affirmance rates for Judge Archer are illustrated in the following chart:
Judge Archer Affirmance Rates
Best Mode 0
Indefiniteness 33
Prevailing Patentee 48
Enablement 50
Obviousness 53
Summary Judgment 59
Validity 60
Claim Construction 63
Literal 63
Inequitable Conduct 64
Infringement 65
Doctr. Equiv. 65
Anticipation 65
Bench Trial 67
Jury Trial 70
Damages 70
Prel. Injunc. 82
Exceptional Case 86
Written Description 100
Perm. Injunc. 100
0 20 40 60 80 100
Percentage

The number of decisions, by issue, for Judge Archer is shown below.
Decisions by Issue, Judge Archer
85
90
75
80
s
on 70 59
cisi 60
e
D 50
f
o 40
r
e 30
b
um 20 8 10 7 11 11
N 10 3 2
0
The number of opinions authored by Judge Archer, by issue, is shown below:
Opinions by Issue, Judge Archer
30 26
22
25
17
20
15
10
5 1 3 1 2 3 0 1
0

The number of decisions on various infringement and validity issues by Judge Archer is shown
below:
Decisions on Infringement and Validity
Issues, Judge Archer
60
60
s
n 50
o
si
ci 40 32
e
D
f 30 20 23
o
er 20
b
um 10 1 4 3 1
N
0
The number of opinions authored by Judge Archer on various infringement and validity issues is
illustrated in the following chart:
Opinions on Infringement and Validity
Issues, Judge Archer
18
18
16
s
n 14
o
ni 12
pi
O 10 8 8
f
o 8 6
r
e
b 6
m
Nu 4 1
2 0 0 0
0
Decision Date Case Name Majority Panel Issue Type Decision
09/01/1995 Allied v. American Archer, Lourie, Validity Vacated
Cyanamid Co., Newman
09/01/1995 Allied v. American Archer, Lourie, Inequitable Vacated
Cyanamid Co., Newman Conduct
09/01/1995 Hoover Group, Inc. Archer, Validity Affirmed
v. Metalcraft, Inc., Clevenger,
Newman
09/01/1995 Hoover Group, Inc. Archer, Infringement Affirmed
v. Metalcraft, Inc., Clevenger,
Newman
09/01/1995 Hoover Group, Inc. Archer, Infringement Reversed
v. Metalcraft, Inc., Clevenger,
Newman
09/01/1995 Hoover Group, Inc. Archer, Claim Reversed
v. Metalcraft, Inc., Clevenger, Construction
Newman
09/01/1995 Hoover Group, Inc. Archer, Attorney's Fees NA
v. Metalcraft, Inc., Clevenger,
Newman
10/24/1995 Munoz v. Strahm Archer, Lourie, Sanctions NA
Farms, Nies
10/24/1995 Munoz v. Strahm Archer, Lourie, Validity Affirmed
Farms, Nies
10/24/1995 Munoz v. Strahm Archer, Lourie, Evidence Affirmed
Farms, Nies
11/03/1995 Gentex v. Donnelly Archer, Claim Affirmed
Corp., Clevenger, Rich Construction
Decision Date Case Name Majority Panel Issue Type Decision
11/03/1995 Gentex v. Donnelly Archer, Infringement Affirmed
Corp., Clevenger, Rich
12/11/1995 In Re Ochiai, Archer, Michel Validity Reversed
02/08/1996 In Re Dirk M. Archer, Michel Validity Reversed
Brouwer,
02/26/1996 Novo Nordisk v. Archer, Lourie, Injunction Vacated
Genentech, Inc., Rich
02/26/1996 Novo Nordisk v. Archer, Lourie, Claim Reversed
Genentech, Inc., Rich Construction
02/26/1996 Novo Nordisk v. Archer, Lourie, Infringement Reversed
Genentech, Inc., Rich
04/04/1996 Merck v. Kessler, Archer, Michel, Patent Term Affirmed, Vacated
Nies Extension
04/04/1996 Merck v. Kessler, Archer, Michel, Jurisdiction NA
Nies
04/08/1996 Bio-Technology v. Archer, Lourie, Injunction Affirmed
Genentech, Rich
04/08/1996 Bio-Technology v. Archer, Lourie, Estoppel Affirmed
Genentech, Rich
Decision Date Case Name Majority Panel Issue Type Decision
04/08/1996 Bio-Technology v. Archer, Lourie, Laches Affirmed
Genentech, Rich
04/08/1996 Bio-Technology v. Archer, Lourie, Unclean Hands Affirmed
Genentech, Rich
04/08/1996 Bio-Technology v. Archer, Lourie, Claim Affirmed
Genentech, Rich Construction
04/08/1996 Bio-Technology v. Archer, Lourie, Infringement Affirmed
Genentech, Rich
04/08/1996 Bio-Technology v. Archer, Lourie, Evidence Affirmed
Genentech, Rich
04/08/1996 Bio-Technology v. Archer, Lourie, Res Judicata Affirmed
Genentech, Rich
04/26/1996 Refac v. Lotus, Archer, Inequitable Affirmed
Clevenger, Conduct
Lourie
05/13/1996 In Re Recreative Archer, Newman, Validity Reversed, Remanded
Technologies, Rich
05/24/1996 Hoover v. Custom Archer, Personal Liability Reversed
Metalcraft, Clevenger,
Newman
05/24/1996 Hoover v. Custom Archer, Venue Affirmed
Metalcraft, Clevenger,
Newman
06/04/1996 Kendall Co. v. Archer, Lourie, Repair Affirmed
Progressive Medical, Schall
Decision Date Case Name Majority Panel Issue Type Decision
08/29/1996 Best Lock v. ILCO, Archer, Lourie Validity Affirmed
Newman (Dissent)
09/19/1996 Bravo Systems v. Archer, Bryson Sanctions Vacated, Remanded
Containment Tech.,
09/19/1996 Bravo Systems v. Archer, Bryson Sanctions NA
Containment Tech.,
10/08/1996 In RE Kemps, Archer, Lourie, Validity Affirmed
Mayer
10/24/1996 Applied Materials v. Archer, Mayer, Claim Affirmed
Advanced Newman Construction
Semicond.,
10/24/1996 Applied Materials v. Archer, Mayer, Claim Affirmed
Advanced Newman Construction
Semicond.,
10/24/1996 Applied Materials v. Archer, Mayer, Infringement Reversed
Advanced Newman
Semicond.,
10/24/1996 Applied Materials v. Archer, Mayer, Infringement Affirmed
Advanced Newman
Semicond.,
10/24/1996 Applied Materials v. Mayer, Newman Validity Affirmed
Advanced
Archer (Dissent)
Semicond.,
10/24/1996 Applied Materials v. Mayer, Newman Validity Affirmed
Advanced
Archer (Dissent)
Semicond.,
Decision Date Case Name Majority Panel Issue Type Decision
10/24/1996 Applied Materials v. Archer, Mayer Validity Affirmed
Advanced
Newman (Dissent)
Semicond.,
11/05/1996 Insituform Archer, Michel, Claim Affirmed
Technologies v. Schall Construction
CAT,
11/05/1996 Insituform Archer, Michel, Claim Reversed
Technologies v. Schall Construction
CAT,
11/05/1996 Insituform Archer, Michel, Infringement Vacated, Remanded
Technologies v. Schall
CAT,
11/05/1996 Insituform Archer, Michel, Infringement Affirmed
Technologies v. Schall
CAT,
11/05/1996 Insituform Archer, Michel, Validity Affirmed
Technologies v. Schall
CAT,
11/06/1996 Alpex Computer v. Archer, Newman, Claim Reversed
Nintendo, Rich Construction
11/06/1996 Alpex Computer v. Archer, Newman, Infringement Reversed
Nintendo, Rich
11/06/1996 Alpex Computer v. Archer, Newman, Infringement Reversed
Nintendo, Rich
11/06/1996 Alpex Computer v. Archer, Newman, Validity Affirmed
Nintendo, Rich
Decision Date Case Name Majority Panel Issue Type Decision
01/03/1997 Micro Chemical Inc. Archer, Lourie Claim Affirmed
v. Great Plains Construction
Chem,
01/03/1997 Micro Chemical Inc. Archer, Lourie Infringement Affirmed
v. Great Plains
Chem,
01/03/1997 Micro Chemical Inc. Archer, Lourie Infringement Affirmed
v. Great Plains
Chem,
01/03/1997 Micro Chemical Inc. Archer, Lourie Infringement Vacated, Remanded
v. Great Plains
Chem,
01/03/1997 Micro Chemical Inc. Archer, Lourie Validity Reversed
v. Great Plains
Mayer (Dissent)
Chem,
01/03/1997 Micro Chemical Inc. Archer, Lourie Validity Reversed
v. Great Plains
Mayer (Dissent)
Chem,
01/03/1997 Micro Chemical Inc. Archer, Lourie Inequitable Affirmed
v. Great Plains Conduct
Chem,
01/09/1997 General Mills, Inc. v. Archer, Friedman Claim Affirmed
Hunt-Wesson, Inc., Construction
Rader (Dissent)
01/09/1997 General Mills, Inc. v. Archer, Friedman Infringement Affirmed
Hunt-Wesson, Inc.,
Rader (Dissent)
01/09/1997 General Mills, Inc. v. Archer, Friedman Infringement Affirmed
Hunt-Wesson, Inc.,
Rader (Dissent)
Decision Date Case Name Majority Panel Issue Type Decision
01/14/1997 Abbott Lab. v. Archer, Infringement Affirmed
Novopharm Limited, Friedman, Rich
01/17/1997 In Re Nancy G. Archer, Michel, Validity Affirmed
Mayne, Rader
01/31/1997 Enercon Industries v. Archer, Michel, Jurisdiction Dismissed
Pillar Corp., Smith
02/05/1997 Kridl and Goodman Archer, Bryson, Interference Affirmed
v. McCormick, Lourie
02/05/1997 Kridl and Goodman Archer, Bryson, Interference Affirmed
v. McCormick, Lourie
03/13/1997 Genentech, Inc. v. Archer, Bryson, Validity Reversed
Novo Nordisk, Lourie
04/03/1997 Judin v. U.S., Archer, Plager, Sanctions Vacated, Remanded
Schall
04/08/1997 Gambro Lundia v. Archer, Lourie, Infringement Affirmed
Baxter Health Care, Rader
04/08/1997 Gambro Lundia v. Archer, Lourie, Inequitable Reversed
Baxter Health Care, Rader Conduct
04/08/1997 Gambro Lundia v. Archer, Lourie, Validity Reversed
Baxter Health Care, Rader
04/08/1997 Gambro Lundia v. Archer, Lourie, Validity Reversed
Baxter Health Care, Rader