HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR PATHAK WILL BE ADMINISTERED OATH OF OFFICE AS ...

197 Pages·2013·1.51 MB·German

29/04/2013 SUPPLEMENTARY LIST
SUPPLEMENTARY LIST FOR TODAY IN CONTINUATION OF THE ADVANCE LIST ALREADY CIRCULATED.
THE WEBSITE OF DELHI HIGH COURT IS www.delhihighcourt.nic.in
INDEX
PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS----------> J-1 TO J-4
REGULAR MATTERS --------------------> R-1 TO R-49
FINAL MATTERS (ORIGINAL SIDE) ------> F-1 TO F-9
ADVANCE LIST------------------------> 1 TO 84
APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)-> 85 TO 93 (FIRST PART)
APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)- 94 TO 110 (SECOND PART)
COMPANY ----------------------------> 111 TO 112
SECOND SUPPLEMENTARY----------------> 113 TO 119
ORIGINAL SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY I)-----> 120 TO 129
HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR PATHAK WILL
BE ADMINISTERED OATH OF OFFICE AS
ADDITIONAL JUDGE OF THIS COURT ON MONDAY,
THE 29th APRIL, 2013 AT 10.00 A.M. BY
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE IN JUDGES'
LOUNGE.
AFTER THE OATH TAKING CEREMONY, THE COURTS
WILL ASSEMBLE AT 10.45 A.M.

NOTES
1. All final hearing matters pending in the category of After Notice Misc.
Matters before Hon'ble DB-I shall be listed in Regular Matters list on their
respective dates of hearing. If the matters are not taken up on actual date
of hearing, these shall be taken up on their turn in the Regular Matters
list.
2. Following directions are issued by Hon'ble DB-II in urgent mentioning
matters:
i) No urgent mentioning shall be entertained, except at 10.30 A.M.
ii) Urgent mentioning shall be entertained only in respect of matters of
Detention and Personal Liberty and matters which cannot brook delay
till the normal next day of listing.

iii) Urgent mentioning shall be entertained only in such cases which are
accompanied by duly filled in “Form For Urgent(Mentioning) Cases For
Listing/Accommodation” in duplicate. Such forms can be obtained from
window No. 4 of the Filing Counter.
A Specimen of the form is also available on the website of Delhi High Court
under the heading “Download”.
3. Hon'ble Mr. Justice S.P. Garg will not be holding Court today. Dates will be
given by the Court Master.
4. Hon'ble Mr. Justice G.P. Mittal will not be holding Court today. Cases of his
Lordship fixed for 29.04.2013 relating to Sexual Offences, Bail Applications &
Criminal Appeals will be heard by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sunil Gaur.
DELETIONS
1. WP(C) 2589/2013 listed before Hon'ble DB-V at item No. 3 is deleted as the
same is fixed for 29.07.2013.
2. CRL.L.P. 189/2013 listed before Hon'ble DB-VIII at item No. 3 is deleted as
the same is listed before Hon'ble DB-VII.
3. WP(C)1538/2013 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Shakdher at item No.18
is deleted as the same is fixed for 08.08.2013.
4. CM APPLN. 5110/2013 in WP(C) 2370/2012 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice
Rajiv Shakdher at item No. 35 in supplementary list is deleted as the same
will be taken up with main case already listed at item No. 32 in advance
cause list.
5. CRL.M.C. 446/2013 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sunil Gaur at item No.5
is deleted as the same is listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Kailash Gambhir.
6. CM APPLN.5174/2013 in WP(C) 450/2013 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice
V.K.Jain at item No.28 is deleted as the same will be listed on 30.04.2013.
NOTICE
I. It is hereby informed that Hon’ble the Chief Justice, on the
recommendation of the Hon’ble Computer Committee, has directed
that in addition to filing of soft copy on CD-R/DVD-R in Company
and Taxation matters, it will be mandatory to file soft copy on
CD-R/DVD-R in all Arbitration matters also w.e.f. 1st April 2013
in addition to the existing paper filing of cases. The procedure
to prepare soft copy is as under:
Use below mentioned formatting style for preparing the document:
Paper size: Foolscap paper
Margins:
Top: 1.5”
Bottom: 1.5”
Left: 1.75”
Justification: Full
Font: Times New Roman
Font size 14
Line Spacing: 1.5”
Footnotes/End Notes: Font size-10
Procedure for documents preparation for filing of soft copy
1. Prepare original text material/documents viz. index, notice of
motion, memo of parties, main petition, interlocutory
applications, etc. in MS-word or Open office, as per format
already prescribed for hard copy.
2. Convert documents into PDF using any PDF converter tool or
inbuilt PDF conversion functionality of word processing
software.
3. Scan the documents viz. notorized affidavit(s) signed
vakalatnama, certified copy of order or award /agreement and
annexures etc. (other than text material) using 300 dpi.
4. Merge both type documents, prepared in MS word or open office
and scanned,in a single PDF and bookmark the documents strictly
as per the index of hard-copy. Burn the merged single file on a
CD-R/DVD-R.
5. Present hard-copy, as usual, along with the CD-R/DVD at the
Delhi High Court filing counter at the time of filing. (Details
of the case be written in black ink using black marker on the CD
mailer (padded) cover as well as on CD under the signature of
counsel).
The Advocate will give an undertaking on the hard-copy in the
following format:
“Certified that the soft copy filed herewith is a replica of the
hard-copy filed.
For any assistance and training please contact Mr. Sarsij Kumar,
System Analyst, and Mr. Zameem Ahmad Khan, Programmer, Computer
Cell, Ground Floor, A-Block, Delhi High Court, New Delhi. (011-
43010101, Ext. no.4563).
NOTE:
Facility of scanning and preparing the soft copy on payment
basis (0.50 paisa per page) has been provided at Filing Counter
No.13,14 for Advocates/Litigants by a private agency.
REGISTRAR[LISTING]
29.04.2013 J-1 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENTS (APPLT. JURISDICTION)
29.04.2013
COURT NO. 1
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW
AT 10.30 A.M
1. LPA 862/2004 ATV PROJECTS INDIA LTD. SHAILESH K. KAPOOR
VS. INDIA OIL CORPORATION LTD AJAY KUMAR
& ANR V.N. KOURA
MONIA ANEJA
SUMEET BENIPAL
2. LPA 337/2010 VIJAY KUMAR SUDHANSHU BATRA
VS. NEW DELHI MUNICIPAL MANU NAYAR
COUNCIL MANOJ KUMAR SINGH
MILAVA BANERJEE
ARPAN BEHL
3. LPA 500/2012 MANAGING COMMITTEE, JYOTI SINGH
CM.APPL. 11726/2012 NAVAL PUBLIC SCHOOL AMANDEEP JOSHI
VS. NEERA CHOPRA & ANR CHETAN LOKUR
VIRAJ R. DATAR
4. LPA 788/2012 MARUTI SUZUKI INDIA LTD A.M. SINGHVI
VS. INDIA TOURISM DEVELOPMENT T.K. GANJU
CORPORATION LTD. & ANR A.K. THAKUR
R.K. MISHRA
AQUIB ALI
C.M. OBEROI
SUREKHA RAMAN
COURT NO. 1
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.K. JAIN
AT 10.30 A.M
1. W.P.(C) 2249/2013 SAMTA ANDOLAN SAMITI M.L. LAHOTY
CM 4277/2013 AND ORS. PABAN K. SHARMA
VS. UNION OF INDIA & ORS GARGI B. BHARALI
SHOBHIT TIWARI
LAL PRATAP SINGH
UMESH PRATAP SINGH
PRADEEP AGGARWAL
RAM NIWAS
GOPAL SANKARANARAYANAN
RAJEEV MEHRA
SACHIN DATTA
DINESH SHARMA
29.04.2013 J-2 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENTS (APPLT. JURISDICTION)
COURT NO. 2
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KISHAN KAUL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI
AT 2.15 P.M.
1. FAO(OS) 554/2010 NATIONAL HYDROELECTRIC POWER SACHIN DATTA
CORPORATION LTD. NEHA GUPTA
VS. GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY TRIDEEP PAIS
LTD. & ORS. ASHWATH SITARAMAN
NATALIA SHIBLI
PRABHSAHAY KAUR
COURT NO.4
(DIVISION BENCH-4)
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP NANDRAJOG
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.KAMESWAR RAO
1. W.P.(C) 4052/2012 COMMISSIONER OF POLICE V.K. TANDON
VS. MUKESH KUMAR YOGESH SAINI
L.R. KHATANA
2. W.P.(C) 3549/2012 COMMISSIONER OF POLICE S.Q. KAZIM
DELHI AND ANR M.H. USMANI
VS. MANDEEP SACHIN CHAUHAN
3. W.P.(C) 3925/2012 COMMISSIONER OF POLICE A.K. TRIVEDI
DELHI ANA ANR DR. S.P. SHARMA
VS. BHAWANI SACHIN CHAUHAN
4. W.P.(C) 3932/2012 GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI A.K. TRIVEDI
AND ORS DR. S.P. SHARMA
VS. HARIPAL ARYA SOURABH AHUJA
COURT NO. 24
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P.K.BHASIN
1. CRL.A.699/2000 SURESH A.J. BHAMBHANI
VS. THE STATE (NCT OF DELHI) LAKSHITA SETHI
BHAVITA MODI
M.N. DUDEJA
COURT NO. 8
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI
1. W.P.(C) 1991/2010 IFCI LIMITED DINKAR SINGH
CM 3988/2010 VS. THE GENERAL SECRETARY S. JANANI
CM 5327/2010 ALL INDIA IFC EMPLOYEES ASSO.
CM 12294/2010
29.04.2013 J-3 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENTS (APPLT. JURISDICTION)
COURT NO. 9
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE VEENA BIRBAL
AT 2.15 P.M.
1. R.C.REV. 33/2013 PAWAN KUMAR GOEL J.C. MAHENDROO
CM 1160/2013 VS. SURESH CHANDER GUPTA & ANR.
CM 58/2013
COURT NO. 12
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURESH KAIT
AT 10.30 A.M.
1. W.P.(C) 1709/2011 RAMU N.S. DALAL
VS. MANAGEMENT OF BENGAL D.P. SINGH
EDUCATIONAL AND CULTURAL AMIT RANA
ASSOCIATION AND ORS. VINAY SABHARWAL
BHUPESH NARULA
ASHISH GUPTA
2. W.P.(C) 1710/2011 SHEELA N.S. DALAL
VS. MANAGEMENT OF BENGAL VINAY SABHARWAL
EDUCATIONAL AND CULTURAL BHUPESH NARULA
ASSOCIATION AND ORS. ASHISH GUPTA
3. MAC.APP 854-57/2005 OM WATI & ORS. RAJINDER GULATI
VS. RAM MAGAN & ORS. NEERAJ SHARMA
4. MAC.APP 901/2011 & NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. D.K. SHARMA
CM 18765/2011 VS. HEM LATA DEVI & ORS. SUDHIR MEHNDIRATTA
4. CRL.REV.P.438/2010 & SAJJAN KUMAR A.K. SHARMA
CRL.M.A. 13980/2010 VS. CBI APOORV SHARMA
ANUJ SHARMA
VINEET MALHOTRA
R.M. TATIA
D.P.SINGH
TARANNUM CHEEMA
H.S. PHOOLKA
VIRENDER VERMA
GURSIMRAN SINGH
KAMNA VOHRA
5. CRL.REV.P.439/2010 & VED PRAKASH PIAL@ VEDU A.K. SHARMA
CRL.M.A. 13984/2010 PRADHAN & ANR. APOORV SHARMA
VS. CBI ANUJ SHARMA
VINEET MALHOTRA
R.M. TATIA
D.P.SINGH
TARANNUM CHEEMA
H.S. PHOOLKA
VIRENDER VERMA
GURSIMRAN SINGH
KAMNA VOHRA
29.04.2013 J-4 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENTS (APPLT. JURISDICTION)
6. W.P.(CRL)205/2010 & BRAHMANAND GUPTA & ANR. A.K. SHARMA
CRL.M.A. 1779/2010 VS. CBI APOORV SHARMA
ANUJ SHARMA
VINEET MALHOTRA
R.M. TATIA
D.P.SINGH
TARANNUM CHEEMA
H.S. PHOOLKA
VIRENDER VERMA
GURSIMRAN SINGH
KAMNA VOHRA
7. CRL.REV.P.113/2011 & SHEELA KAUR H.S. PHOOLKA
CRL.M.A. 3018-19/2011 VS. CBI & ORS. VIRENDER VERMA
GURSIMRAN SINGH
KAMNA VOHRA
D.P.SINGH
TARANNUM CHEEMA
COURT NO. 14
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.K. JAIN
AT 10.30 A.M
1. W.P.(C) 4895/2011 PINKI PUNIA NISHANT DATTA
VS. DDA RAJEEV BANSAL
RAHUL BHANDARI
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
27TH APRIL, 2013 REGISTRAR (LISTING)
29.04.2013 FOR PRONOUNCMENT OF JUDGMENT (ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)
COURT NO. 26
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.K. SHALI
AT 4.00 P.M.
1. CS(OS) 758/2008 MR. ANAND J. DATWANI ABNINAV VASISHT,RAJAT
Vs. MRS. GEETI BHAGAT DATWANI NAVET,VINAY SHARMA,RAMAN
AND ORS KUMAR,NEERAJ KAUL

****
COURT NO. 23 (OS-A)
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN
AT 10.30 A.M
26. CS(OS) 1742/2011 SARDAR BALVINDER SINGH AND ANR MOHIT CHAUDHARY,JITENDER
Vs. P.N MALHOTRA AND ORS CHAUDHARY,SHILPA CHOHAN,
JITENDER,PRAGYA SINGH
COURT NO.17 (OS-B)
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M. L. MEHTA
AT 2.15 P.M.
19. CS(OS) 2185/2001 NIRLON LTD., ANSHU MAHJAN,ADITYA MADAN,SN
Vs. UNION BANK OF INDIA MEHROTRA,VIVEK,RAJNESH RANJAN,
C+ A.K MATA,SATYAJIT A DESAI,
ANSHU MAHAGUN,MANJULA GANDHI
20. CS(OS) 37/2003 R.S.CHARITABLE TRUST S.C.NANDA, VIKAS DHAWAN,
Vs. STANDARD CHARTERED RAVI SINGH, SANJAY GUPTA,RAVI
GRINDLAYS BANK AND ANR. E+ SHANKAR,T.K. GANJU,RANVIR
SINGH,TILESHWAR PRASAD,SHRUTI
KUMARI,ADITYA GUPTA,SUMIT
BANSAL,A. MATHUR
21. CS(OS) 1797/2003 K.L.SACHDEVA ANIL GROVER,ROMESH K KANWAR,
I.A. 69/2012 Vs. M.C.D S.N. GUPTA,RUCHITRA KAPOOR,PANKAJ
D+ BATRA,ADITYA SHANKAR,S.P. SINGH,
NOOPUR SINGHAL,RAHUL
SRIVASTAVA,SUPARNA SRIVASTAVA
22. CS(OS) 1228/2004 TATA SONS LTD. MR. PRAVIN ANAND,ACHUTHAN
I.A. 7287/2004 Vs. AMIT MAHNA AND ORS. SREEKUMAR,V. GURUMOORTHI,A.
AC+ SREEKUMAR,UDITA
23. CS(OS) 2367/2012 HEINZ INDIA PVT LTD R.BHANSALI,CHANDER
Vs. M/S SHREEJEE REMEDIES SHEKHAR,ANURADHA SALHOTRA,C S
PATNEY,ZEESHAN KHAN,CHANDER
SHEKAR PATNEY,D.C DANI
29.04.2013 R- 1 ( Regular Matters)
29.04.2013 REGULAR MATTERS
COURT NO. 1
(DIVISION BENCH-1)
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
H O N'BLE MR. JUSTICE J AYANT NATH
[NOTE I: COUNSELS ARE REQUESTED TO PAGINATE THEIR FILES IN CONFORMITY WITH
THE COURT FILE IN ADVANCE.
NOTE II: COUNSELS ARE REQUESTED TO PROVIDE LIST OF BOOKS/ACTS ON WHICH THEY
ARE RELYING IN ADVANCE.
NOTE III: IN REGULAR MATTERS & FINAL HEARING MATTERS , THE PARTIES SHOULD FILE
SHORT SYNOPSIS RUNNING INTO NOT MORE THAN 3 PAGES EACH TWO DAYS IN
ADVANCE.
NOTE-IV: REGULAR MATTERS WILL BE TAKEN UP IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER IN
THE FOLLWING MANNER:
(i)PART-I(LPA & SENIOR CITIZEN MATTERS)---- MONDAY,TUESDAY,
THURSDAY & FRIDAY

(ii)PART-II(PIL)---------------------------- WEDNESDAY
PART-I
REGULAR MATTERS
1 . LPA 587/2008---------| GOVT. OF N.C.T. OF DELHI AND AVNISH AHLAWAT,MANINDER
CM APPL. 14092/2008 ANR. ACHARYA,RAMAN KAPUR,
WITH LPA 590/2008 | Vs. SANJEEV KUMAR H. TANEJA
LPA 615/2008
PH |
NOT TILL 29.4.2013
2 . LPA 590/2008 GOVT. OF N.C.T. OF DELHI AND AVNISH AHLAWAT
CM APPL. 14153/2008 | ANR.
NOT TILL 29.4.2013 Vs. DHANNU DABI
3 . LPA 615/2008 | DHANNU DABI MANU MRIDUL,MANINDER
CM APPL. 14457/2008 Vs. GOVT. OF N.C.T. OF DELHI ACHARYA,AVNISH AHLAWAT
NOT TILL 29.4.2013 AND ORS.
4 . LPA 710/2008---------| NARESH KUMAR VERMA RAHUL SINHA
NOT TILL 29.4.2013 Vs. D.S.S.S.B. AND ORS.
5. LPA 1071/2006 MANGE RAM PAWANJIT S.BINDRA,MANINDER
Vs. SPEAKER, LOK SABHA AND ANR ACHARYA,YASHISH CHANDRA
NB: HMJ S. RAVINDRA BHAT
6. LPA 2006/2006 BALWAN SINGH AND ORS SUMIT BANSAL, RAJIV
LPA 2007-2011/2006 Vs. DDA AND ORS BANSAL, RAMESH MAHAJAN,
CM APPL. 14062/2006 AMIT MAHAJAN, D.S.
CM APPL. 3365/2008 KHATRI, VIBHA DATTA
NB: HMJ S. RAVINDRA BHAT MAKHIJA, PHILEMON
MEHENDRALANA, V.K.
TANDON, AMIT SINGH,MS
REETA KAUL,MAHENDRA RANA
7. LPA 1299/2007 CEMENT CORPORATION OF INDIA SWETA BHARTI,R.K.
NB: HMJ S. RAVINDRA BHAT LTD. GHAWANA,PUNEET
Vs. LIFE INSURANCE SHARMA,RAVINDER SETHI
CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD. AND
ORS.
8. LPA 1317/2007 SHRI S.C. AHUJA K.VENKATRAMAN,MADHU TEWATIA
NB: HMJ S. RAVINDRA BHAT Vs. N.D.M.C. AND ORS
9. LPA 1357/2007 GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI AND ANR PARMINDER SINGH
CM APPL. 16426/2007 Vs. CHARANJIT KAUR NEGI
NB: HMJ S. RAVINDRA BHAT