Alfred Marshall: Economist 1842-1924 (Great Thinkers in Economics)

224 Pages·2007·1.09 MB·English

by  Peter Groenewegen

Alfred Marshall
Economist 1842–1924
Peter Groenewegen
GreatThinkersinEconomicsSeries
Series Editor: Professor A.P. Thirlwall, is Professor of Applied Economics,
UniversityofKent,UK.
GreatThinkersinEconomicsisdesignedtoilluminatetheeconomicsofsomeof
thegreathistoricalandcontemporaryeconomistsbyexploringtheinteractions
betweentheirlivesandwork,andtheeventssurroundingthem.Thebookswill
bebriefandwritteninastylethatmakesthemnotonlyofinteresttoprofessional
economists,butalsointelligibleforstudentsofeconomicsandtheinterestedlay
person.
Titlesinclude:
WilliamJ.Barber
GUNNARMYRDAL
AnIntellectualBiography
PaulDavidson
JOHNMAYNARDKEYNES
PeterD.Groenewegen
ALFREDMARSHALL
Forthcomingtitlesinclude:
EsbenSlothAnderson
JOSEPHA.SCHUMPETER
ATheoryofSocialandEconomicEvolution
MichaelSzenbergandLalRamrattan
FRANCOMODIGLIANI
AMindthatNeverRests
CharlesRowley
JAMESMCGILLBUCHANAN
PoliticalEconomistandEconomicPhilosopher(1919–)
MichaelA.Lebowitz
KARLMARX
JohnKing
NICOLASKALDOR
AlessandroRoncaglia
PIEROSRAFFA
JulioLopezandMichaëlSamuelAssous
KALECKI’STHEORYOFCAPITALISTECONOMIES
GerhardMichaelAmbrosi
ARTHURC.PIGOU
J.R.Stanfield
JOHNKENNETHGALBRAITH
July23,2007 15:24 MAC/ALM Page-i 1403_996206_01_preiv
WarrenYoung
ROYHARROD
G.C.Harcourt
JOANROBINSONANDHERCIRCLE
RogerMiddleton
ROBERTSOLOW
GreatThinkersinEconomics
SeriesStandingOrderISBN978–14039–8555–2(Hardback)
978–14039–8556–9(Paperback)
(outsideNorthAmericaonly)
You can receive future titles in this series as they are published by placing a
standingorder.Pleasecontactyourbookselleror,incaseofdifficulty,writetous
attheaddressbelowwithyournameandaddress,thetitleoftheseriesandthe
ISBNquotedabove.
Customer Services Department, Macmillan Distribution Ltd, Houndmills,
Basingstoke,HampshireRG216XS,England
July23,2007 15:24 MAC/ALM Page-ii 1403_996206_01_preiv
Alfred Marshall
Economist 1842–1924
Peter Groenewegen
EmeritusProfessorofEconomics,UniversityofSydney,Australia
July23,2007 15:24 MAC/ALM Page-iii 1403_996206_01_preiv
©PeterGroenewegen2007
Allrightsreserved.Noreproduction,copyortransmissionofthis
publicationmaybemadewithoutwrittenpermission.
Noparagraphofthispublicationmaybereproduced,copiedortransmitted
savewithwrittenpermissionorinaccordancewiththeprovisionsofthe
Copyright,DesignsandPatentsAct1988,orunderthetermsofanylicence
permittinglimitedcopyingissuedbytheCopyrightLicensingAgency,
90TottenhamCourtRoad,LondonW1T4LP.
Anypersonwhodoesanyunauthorizedactinrelationtothispublication
maybeliabletocriminalprosecutionandcivilclaimsfordamages.
Theauthorhasassertedhisrighttobeidentified
astheauthorofthisworkinaccordancewiththeCopyright,
DesignsandPatentsAct1988.
Firstpublished2007by
PALGRAVEMACMILLAN
Houndmills,Basingstoke,HampshireRG216XSand
175FifthAvenue,NewYork,N.Y.10010
Companiesandrepresentativesthroughouttheworld
PALGRAVEMACMILLANistheglobalacademicimprintofthePalgrave
MacmillandivisionofSt.Martin’sPress,LLCandofPalgraveMacmillanLtd.
Macmillan(cid:2)isaregisteredtrademarkintheUnitedStates,UnitedKingdom
andothercountries.PalgraveisaregisteredtrademarkintheEuropean
Unionandothercountries.
ISBN-13:978(cid:3)1(cid:3)4039(cid:3)9620(cid:3)6hardback
ISBN-10:1(cid:3)4039(cid:3)9620(cid:3)2hardback
Thisbookisprintedonpapersuitableforrecyclingandmadefromfully
managedandsustainedforestsources.Logging,pulpingandmanufacturing
processesareexpectedtoconformtotheenvironmentalregulationsofthe
countryoforigin.
AcataloguerecordforthisbookisavailablefromtheBritishLibrary.
AcatalogrecordforthisbookisavailablefromtheLibraryofCongress.
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
16 15 14 13 12 11 10 09 08 07
PrintedandboundinGreatBritainby
AntonyRoweLtd,ChippenhamandEastbourne
July23,2007 15:24 MAC/ALM Page-iv 1403_996206_01_preiv
Contents
Preface viii
1 Introduction:AlfredMarshall,aGiantAmong
Economists 1
1.1 Marshall’sworkasaneconomist 2
1.2 Marshall’sspecificcontributionstoeconomics 3
1.3 Marshall’smajorbooks 5
1.4 Marshall’sOfficialPapersandhistwo
smallerbooks 10
1.5 Thebookinoutline 12
1.6 Marshall’sgreateminencedemonstrated 13
2 Family,ChildhoodandEducation(1842–65) 16
2.1 Childhoodandschool(1842–61) 18
2.2 Undergraduate at St John’s College, Cambridge
(1861–65) 20
3 Marshall’sMoralSciencesApprenticeshipandSearchfor
aNewVocation(1866–77) 28
3.1 MarshallatCliftonCollegeandasFellowat
StJohn’s 31
3.2 MembershipofCambridgeclubsandgraduallossof
faith 32
3.3 Philosophicalinquiryincludingfourphilosophical
papers 34
3.4 Fromphilosophytoeconomics 36
3.5 AlfredMarshallandthePoliticalEconomyofJohn
StuartMill 38
3.6 OtherearlyinfluencesonMarshall’seconomics 40
3.7 Earlyteachingandwritingineconomics 41
3.8 Travel,engagement,marriageanddeparturefrom
Cambridge(1877) 47
v
July23,2007 15:25 MAC/ALM Page-v 1403_996206_02_previi
vi Contents
4 BristolandOxford(1877–84)andTwo‘Small’Books
(1879) 49
4.1 PrincipalandProfessorofPoliticalEconomyatBristol
UniversityCollege(1877–81,1882–83) 50
4.2 AyearinSicilyandEurope(1881–82) 52
4.3 EconomicsLectureratBalliolCollege,Oxford
(1883–84) 53
4.4 Ashortbookforbeginners:TheEconomicsofIndustry
(1879,1881) 55
4.5 Puretheoryofforeigntradeandofdomesticvalue
(1879) 67
5 Professor at Cambridge (1885–1908) and Adviser to
Governments 71
5.1 Thepresentpositionofeconomics(1885) 72
5.2 ProfessorialteachingatCambridge(1885–1908) 74
5.3 ThenatureofMarshall’sCambridgestudents 77
5.4 ThenewEconomicsandPoliticsTripos(1903)andits
consequences 78
5.5 Givingadvicetogovernments 81
5.6 MemberoftheLabourCommission(1891–94) 90
6 WritingandRevisingthePrinciples(1882–1922) 94
6.1 PreparingthefirsteditionofthePrinciples(1880–90) 95
6.2 Thefirstedition(1890):contentsandreception 97
6.3 Adangerousinterruption:breakingtheflowwithan
earlysecondedition(1891)andasummary,Elements
oftheEconomicsofIndustry (1892) 102
6.4 Anindefinitelypostponedsecondvolume 103
6.5 ThefinaleditionsofthePrinciples,includingthe
definitiveeighthedition(1920) 106
6.6 ThesignificanceofthePrinciples 111
7 PoliticalandSocialThought:‘AYouthfulTendencyto
Socialism’;ChangingViewsontheWomen’sIssue;anda
TasteforAdvocacyandOccasionalControversy 116
7.1 Marshall’spoliticalandsocialthought–anoverview 117
7.2 Atasteforoccasionallyinitiatingcontroversy:quarrels
withCunningham,Böhm-BawerkandPearson 122
7.3 Housingpolicy,thepoor,poorlawreformandthe
CharityOrganisationSociety 125
July23,2007 15:25 MAC/ALM Page-vi 1403_996206_02_previi
Contents vii
7.4 Member of learned economic societies and
formationoftheBritishEconomicAssociation
(laterRoyalEconomicSociety) 130
7.5 Marshall’sshiftingopinionontertiaryeducation
(anddegrees)forwomenatCambridge 133
7.6 Concludingcomments 137
8 Retirement and Industry and Trade (1919): An
ImportantCompanionVolumetothePrinciples 139
8.1 Retirementandfinallecture 141
8.2 Electing Marshall’s successor as Professor of
PoliticalEconomy 143
8.3 Learning,writingandcontinuingcontactwith
studentsandcolleagues 145
8.4 Aprincipledwareffort(1914–18) 147
8.5 Constructingthefirst‘companionvolume’tothe
Principles 150
8.6 ContentsandreceptionofIndustryandTrade 152
8.7 Conclusion 160
9 FinalYearsandSomeFurtherVolumes(1919–24) 162
9.1 Thesageinoldage(1919–24) 163
9.2 Money,CreditandCommerce –writing,contentsand
reception 168
9.3 Abookonprogressthatneverwas 173
9.4 Finaldaysanddeath(July1924) 179
9.5 Concludingremarks 183
10 ARichandEnduringLegacy 185
10.1 Ageneroustestatorydisposition 186
10.2 Asubstantialdoctrinallegacy 189
10.3 Directandindirect‘pupils’toformaCambridge
School 193
10.4 Finalconcludingremarksonanenduringlegacy 199
Bibliography 201
ChronologicalBibliographyofMarshall’sWritings 204
Index 207
July23,2007 15:25 MAC/ALM Page-vii 1403_996206_02_previi
Preface
This book on Marshall draws heavily on material contained in my
biography of him published by Edward Elgar in 1995 under the title
A Soaring Eagle. Alfred Marshall 1842–1924. Most of the biographical
material in this study of Marshall as a major British economist derives
from the research carried out for the earlier volume. However, the
present book is not to be taken simply as a condensed version of
the 1995 biography. Two features of the new work differentiate these
products.ThefirstisthatthenewbookemphasisesMarshall’sworkasan
economist to a far greater extent than the 1995 biography by carefully
outlining Marshall’s economic ideas in considerable detail. Secondly,
thenewbookisabletodrawonthetenyearsofnewMarshallresearch
byagrowingnumberofMarshallscholars.Ofthese,thepublicationin
1996ofJohnWhitaker’sthreevolumeeditionofMarshall’scorrespond-
ence is particularly noted, as is that of the Elgar Companion to Marshall
publishedtenyearslaterin2006.
As part of a series on Great Thinkers in Economics, the emphasis of
thisbookhastobeonMarshalltheeconomist.Thisallowsnotonlyan
overviewofthehostofimportantthingsMarshallsaidasaneconomist
overthefivedecadesfromthelate1860swhichhedevotedtostudying
economics but also gives an opportunity to appreciate the continuing
relevanceofsomanycrucialaspectsofhiseconomics.Inshort,emphasis
in the book is on Marshall’s economic method and ideas as developed
by him over half a century in his various books and articles and on
the manner in which these were passed on to the many pupils whom
he had taught himself, who then in turn passed it on to their pupils.
Thebook,therefore,alsohassomethingtosayontheeconomicschool
Marshall created by not only presenting major aspects of the nature of
Marshall’s economics, but also by addressing the manner in which it
wasgraduallydiffusedovervariouspartsoftheworld.
OnefurthercomparativecommentcanbemadeonthisMarshallbook
andits1995predecessor.Inthisbook,footnoteshavebeencompletely,
anddeliberately,avoided.Allreferencesareprovidedinthetextbythe
Harvardmethod.
Thisprefacealsoprovidesanopportunitytothankthegeneraleditor
oftheseries,TonyThirlwall,forhiscarefulcopy-editingofthefirstdraft,
tothebenefitofmystyleandsomeoftheothercontentsaswell.
viii
July23,2007 15:25 MAC/ALM Page-viii 1403_996206_03_prex